Very thoughtful response. Curious when you say in 2012 you were insulin resistant and after aspirin and niacinimide it WENT AWAY....what combination of factors did you evaluate to make that assessment? Labwork, loss of fat etc?Yes and no. I introduced this post since some people have blood sugar issues when getting on the Peat diet. That pathological reason is not the Peat diet but the fact that through years of burning fat they have become insulin resistant, so eating glucose initially results in high blood glucose. In other words, hypothyroid people have high adrenalin and cortisol and as such lose muscle, have high lipolysis and through the Randle cycle are unable to metabolize glucose properly. Some of the B vitamins, like biotin, are very helpful in maintaining proper glucose control and can help restore insulin sensitivity while the person works on lowering the stress hormones. I, personally, also had blood sugar issues back in 2012 when I first tried the Peat diet but they went away after a few months on 1,500mg niacinamide and high dose aspirin. So, if your insulin sensitivity is fine then you will have no problems with the Peat diet.
It's really that simple really. If you have chronic stress, your sympathetic system will be in overdrive and there may even be some adaptive changes so that it stays overactive even after months on the Peat diet. So, high adrenalin and high cortisol due to high stress will keep you insulin resistant until these hormones are lowered somehow and excessive lipolysis stops. How you lower stress hormones is a whole different issue. Some people do fine just by increasing sugar intake, other may need supplementation with aspirin and the B vitamins, and then others still may need anti-stress drugs like clonidine and cyproheptadine. Remember, insulin resistance is reversible, and has been done many times. Some of the most effective drugs are inhibitors of 11beta-HSD1, which is repsonsible for synthesizing cortisol. If the person is in the group where the Peat diet is making things worse, I would consider taking some of the vitamins and supplements mentioned on the forum, and if that does not work either it's time to talk to your doctor about clonidine/cyproheptadine/bromocriptine/lisuride and so on. Bromocriptine is approved for treating type II diabetes in the USA. Why do you think this is so? Because it lowers both adrenaline and cortisol and lowers free fatty acids.
So, my gripes with the Peat diet were due to my own ignorance at the time. With enough reading and experimentation you will find out the man is right just about 100% of the time.
Here is some other food for thought. If stress is really not good for us or for any of the studied animals so far then try to think about how valid is the hypothesis of "progress through stress and survival of the fittest".
Yes, I do mean the current theory of evolution and widely accepted business practices (purportedly modeled after evolution). There is no reasonable doubt about the validity of evolution as a theory of organisms evolving. I am questioning the part that is happens through constant stress and survival strain. How can you expect an organism to continuously evolve into a higher being if constant stress is the hallmark of regress??!