The Case For Water Fluoridation May Be Nothing But A Corporate Plot

haidut

Member
Joined
Mar 18, 2013
Messages
17,435
Location
USA / Europe
When the mighty "trend-setter of the masses" (as The Atlantic magazine is known in the journalism industry) publishes an extensive article exposing the fraud and lack of evidence of benefit in regards to water fluoridation, you know that a scandal is brewing. The Atlantic has been in bed with corporate interests for decades, and if it writes on such a "controversial" topic it means the fraud/stupidity has become impossible to conceal any longer. Despite being one of the pillars of modern public health achievements, the topic of water fluoridation has actually been contentions from the very onset of the issue/debate, more than century ago. One just needs to type "fluoride health risks" into PubMed to see that studies demonstrating the negative effects of fluoride on systemic health go back all the way to the early 20th century, and some of them are even older. I posted a few other recent reviews calling for re-evaluation of the water fluoridation policy, but the coverage by The Atlantic is by far the most direct discussion I have seen on the corrupt influence industrial/corporate interests have had on public health policy in the Western world.

Exposure To Fluoride Actually Damages Teeth, Even At Low Concentrations
Drinking Fluoridated Water During Pregnancy May Lower IQ (in Sons)

Maybe, we will now start seeing class-action lawsuits similar to the ones for talc, titanium dioxide and breast implants, and that will finally see some change for the better when it comes to the quality of water most people are exposed to on a continuous basis even if they do their best to avoid it. The fact that nations with non-fluoridated water have better dental health (as the article itself states) should be enough of a clue to the general public that, just as with so many other medical "miracles", the massive exposure to fluoride of generations of Americans is little more than criminal enterprise promoted/marketed/sold to the general public by some of the best PR companies in the world.

Fluoridation May Not Prevent Cavities, Scientific Review Shows
Is There Still a Good Case for Water Fluoridation?

"...Then I wondered: How much fluoride is in my water, and how did public-health officials set the dose? Fluoride in large quantities is bad news. Potential side effects, I quickly discovered, include joint pain, bone fractures, sperm decline, dementia, premature puberty, gastrointestinal distress, immune-system dysfunction, (possibly) cancer, and (also possibly) lower IQ in children. Children have smaller bodies than adults and thus are at risk of relatively greater exposure when they drink. In calculating the dose, I thought, the authorities must have taken into account the weird thirsty kid who guzzles water by the quart. But if they lower the dose to avoid harming that child, where would that leave my mother-in-law, who for some reason has decided she no longer wants to drink much water at all? Is she getting shortchanged?"

"...McKay contacted a famous Chicago dentist (famous in dental circles, anyway) and got him to describe the syndrome to the Colorado state dental association. Hardly anyone paid attention. Trying again, McKay and the Chicago dentist evaluated students at Colorado College, in Colorado Springs. They found that students raised in Colorado Springs had discolored teeth, whereas students from other areas had normal teeth. Hardly anyone paid attention. The two researchers then published an article, “An Investigation of Mottled Teeth: An Endemic Developmental Imperfection of the Enamel of the Teeth Heretofore Unknown in the Literature of Dentistry.” Unknown in the Literature of Dentistry! Still, hardly anyone paid attention. In the 1930s, McKay and others identified the staining agent: naturally occurring fluoride compounds in water supplies. (This kind of staining, along with the other negative effects of fluorine absorption by bones and ligaments, is now called fluorosis.) The researchers also discovered something else: Although the staining looked terrible, people with fluoride stains had fewer decayed and missing teeth. A small group of dentists began agitating to add low levels of fluoride to drinking water—low enough to avoid staining and also low enough to be safe."

"...Those dentists would soon get corporate reinforcement. Fluorine, a chemical element, is lethal in small doses and extremely reactive. Fluorides—compounds of fluorine—can be nearly as toxic but are much more stable. They are a common waste product of the fertilizer, pesticide, refrigeration, glass, steel, and aluminum industries. In the ’30s, many of these industries were facing protests and lawsuits for poisoning workers, polluting the soil, and contaminating water supplies. Understandably, executives were thrilled to discover that the chemicals they had to get rid of because they could seep into city water systems might be gotten rid of by being jettisoned into city water systems. Less understandably, some later anti-fluoridation activists described the corporate embrace of fluoridation as evidence of a Communist plot. It was more like a capitalist plot. From 1921 to 1932, the secretary of the Treasury was Andrew W. Mellon, a founder of the Aluminum Company of America, better known as Alcoa. The U.S. Public Health Service was then under the jurisdiction of the Treasury Department. In January 1931, Alcoa chemists discovered high levels of fluoride in the water in and around Bauxite, Arkansas, an Alcoa company town. By May, at Mellon’s urging, a Public Health Service dentist had been assigned to examine the link between fluoride and reduced cavities. Eight years later, a biochemist at the Mellon Institute, in Pittsburgh, became the first researcher to call for the widespread fluoridation of water."

"...Starting in 1945, tests were conducted in Grand Rapids, Michigan, and Newburgh, New York. Both cities added fluoride to their water. In both cases, the control was a nearby city that did not add fluoride. The experiments were supposed to continue for at least a decade, with dentists in each city examining their patients to evaluate long-term effects. As it happened, one of the control cities fluoridated its water within seven years because its citizens had heard rumors about the benefits."

"...The differences between the two graphs don’t leap out at the viewer. Nonfluoridated nations such as Belgium, Luxembourg, and Denmark actually have better dental health by this measure than the United States, one of the world’s fluoridation champions. Finland, Germany, Japan, the Netherlands, Sweden, and Switzerland tried fluoridation, abandoned it years later—and saw no rise in tooth decay. What’s going on?"

"...One of the lesser-known advantages of government-run health-care systems, such as Britain’s National Health Service, is the fact that because taxpayers are funding everything, the government occasionally tries to determine whether the money is being spent usefully. In 1999, the government asked the NHS to “carry out an up-to-date expert scientific review of fluoride and health.” A research team based at the University of York evaluated every study of fluoridation it could find—about 3,200 of them. The team’s conclusion was, it said, “surprising.” Despite the long fight over fluoridation, few of the thousands of studies counted as “high-quality research.” The implication was that Britain had been tinkering with its water supply with little empirical support. Trevor Sheldon, the head of the York review’s advisory board, was blunt: There’s really hardly any evidence” that fluoridation works, he told Newsweek. “And if anything there may be some evidence the other way.” These findings were respectfully ignored."

"...To evaluate the efficacy of water fluoridation, the Cochrane researchers wanted to select properly conducted scientific research, discarding studies that were badly designed (too few participants to produce sound data, for example) or incompetently executed (for instance, the researchers didn’t follow their own protocols). To evaluate the studies, the team used two simple but strict criteria: They needed to have two large groups of subjects, one with fluoride (the intervention group) and one without (the control group), and each group had to be examined at least two times. Moreover, the studies needed to be prospective (meaning the scientists announced beforehand what they were looking for, then measured it) as opposed to retrospective (meaning the scientists sifted through historical data looking for patterns). Scrutinizing medical databases, the Cochrane team found 4,677 fluoridation studies. All but 155 of them—20 that focused on tooth decay, and 135 that focused on dental fluorosis—failed to meet the two criteria. Worse, all of the tooth-decay studies and all but a handful of the fluorosis studies were, in the jargon, “at high risk of bias”—for example, variables such as age and income hadn’t been properly taken into account. The Grand Rapids study is an example of these problems. Not only was it cut short when the control city, Muskegon, started fluoridating its water, but the experimenters had not established whether the two populations had similar incomes or ethnic backgrounds. Nor did the researchers evaluate people’s teeth blindly, by taking X-rays to be examined by technicians who did not know which group a patient belonged to. Instead the study dentists simply looked into patients’ mouths and subjectively reported what they saw—a recipe for what is called “confirmation bias,” in which people tend to interpret what they see in ways that reinforce their prior beliefs."
 

haidut

Member
Thread starter
Joined
Mar 18, 2013
Messages
17,435
Location
USA / Europe
This probably should've been obvious but I found out that most soft drinks and bottled drinks are fluoridated depending on the water source they use Assessing fluoride levels of carbonated soft drinks - PubMed. Maybe one of the reasons I feel so much better in Russia vs. the US?

It is possible. Also, I think most sodas outside the US are sweetened with sugar instead of HCFS. The latter contains a lot of unmetabolized starch and as such is inflammatory and its calorie count is 2-3 times higher than what is listed on the label.
 

jamies33

Member
Joined
Nov 14, 2017
Messages
1,471
Location
Canada
The indoctrination in favour of fluoridation is to reduce child tooth cavities, and to that effect, they have statistics which "prove" its efficacy
 

haidut

Member
Thread starter
Joined
Mar 18, 2013
Messages
17,435
Location
USA / Europe
The indoctrination in favour of fluoridation is to reduce child tooth cavities, and to that effect, they have statistics which "prove" its efficacy

Right, but all those more modern studies are observational. The original "intervention" trials in Michigan from the 1950s turned out to be flawed. So, as of now there is no good evidence supporting fluoridation on a mass scale. At least in the form of ingestable tap water, which is much more dangerous than rubbing fluoridated paste on the teeth without ingesting.
 

Jib

Member
Joined
Mar 20, 2013
Messages
467
Have seen a couple people here recommend iodine for fluoride detox. I notice I feel better when taking a combination product that contains Lugol's solution and sodium selenite, about 25mcg selenium and 6mg iodine per drop. Been taking 2-3 a day and have noticed consistently better mood and energy.

Haven't found a successful (and affordable) filter system that removes fluoride yet.
 

managing

Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2014
Messages
2,262
I started avoiding fluoridated water and using toothpaste w/o fluoride 35 years ago. I am 51 and have never had a single cavity. I also brush every other day. I consider flossing more important than brushing and have great gums. My dentist always raves about how diligent my brushing routine must be. I tell him I don't use fluoride, but he chooses not to focus on that.
 

DMF

Member
Joined
Sep 5, 2012
Messages
213
Water is the only substance I use for oral health. I give all 4 corners of my mouth a good rinsing twice sometimes thrice first thing in the a.m. Each successive rinse looks clearer in the glass bottle as they rid the mouth of residual acids that form overnight. All you have to do is stick a PH strip in them to see. If instead you brush W/toothpaste and PH strip that, the acids are a mile high.
So much for "gum disease"/ "tooth decay"....
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
bzmazu Hey Drinkers....The case for Vitamin-Enriched Alcohol Alcohol, Tobacco, Drugs 3
Tash Mum just had the Pfizer vaccine - what's the case to make to stop the rest of my family taking it Viruses, Parasites, Fungus, Vaccines 43
T Can Someone Lay Out A Factual Case That Refined Sugars And Other Stimulants Waste The Bod Resources? Diet 5
michael94 George-Floyd-Case Anomalies ( And Likelihood Of A Psy Op ) Political Talk, Alternative World Theories 30
P What Are You Doing In Case Of Famine? Society 78
J Homeade Baby Formula As Back Up In Case Wife Struggles Producing Breast Milk Health 4
charlie US Hospitals Receive As Much As $471,000 For Every COVID-19 Case They Report Breaking News 2
cinderella An Interesting Case Study Of A 49 Year Old Woman Thyroid and Hormones 0
U Can CO2 Be Bad In A Case Of Injured Nervous System? CO2, Bag Breathing 1
I Philly Jury Hands Johnson & Johnson $8 Billion Verdict In Risperdal Case Over Male Breast Growth Supplements, Pharmaceutical Drugs 0
F Gastritis: A Case For Glutamine? Digestion 17
charlie The Case Of Mistaken Identity: How Pellagra Now Thought To Be Rare Became Known As Celiac Disease Digestion, Gut Flora 12
tankasnowgod Case Study: Low Dose Acetazolamide Leads To Weight Loss CO2, Bag Breathing 8
G Photobiomodulation And Photodynamic Cosmetic Therapy On Hair Growth: Case Report Hair & Nails 1
Beefcake Case Of Woman Consuming Excess Bananas Presented With Hyperkalemia And Hyperdopaminemia Scientific Studies 24
Obi-wan A Case For High ROS, Antioxidants Are Useless And Potentially Harmful! Health 133
S A Case Of Chronic Low Grade Acidosis Ask For Help or Advice 56
A Can Someone Explain The Case Against Vegetables Here? Discussing Dietary Models 6
Elchapchapchapo How I Have Practically Cured My Case Of Brain Fog Mental Issues 22
charlie RFK Jr. Wins Case Against U.S. Government For Vaccine Safety Violations Vaccines 7
L Successful Human Scar Regeneration By Topical Iodine: A Case Report: An Interim (3.5 Year) Summary Articles & Scientific Studies 32
S Use Case For Antihistamines? Supplements, Pharmaceutical Drugs 17
M A Case For Wheat Diet, Recipes 36
raypeatclips Prolactin And IBS. Case Report Of IBS Cured By Cabergoline Scientific Studies 3
B A Case Of Jock Itch And Possible Coconut Oil Cause Male Issues 13
Frankdee20 Clintons And Obama Administration Colluding W/ The Russians, Nuclear Bribery Case, FBI Allows Political Talk, Alternative World Theories 24
R I Have High Serotonin Levels, But Trypthophan Helped Me - Strange Case Cortisol, Serotonin, Histamine 3
Pointless What To Do In Case Of Nuclear Fallout Radiation 17
Mito The Case Against The Case Against Sugar Sugar, Honey 0
L Case Western Reserve University Research Reveals Important Cancer Clues Cancer, Degenerative Diseases 1
ShirtTieFitness The Case For Raw Honey Beverages, Fruits, Sugars 11
M Methylene Blue For Clinical Anaphylaxis Treatment: A Case Report Articles & Scientific Studies 2
Drareg G6PDH Issue Caused Sparse Hair In 12 Year Old Boy,rare But Interesting Case Scientific Studies 0
tonto Frustration With Mainstream Thinking - Case Of Normal Pressure Hydrocephalus Symptoms, Causes 4
J A Case Of Serotonin Syndrome Following Cyproheptadine Withdrawal Scientific Studies 6
Peata Article, the Case for Drinking as Much Coffee As you Like... Coffee 4
Kasra A Case For Intermittent Fasting Articles & Scientific Studies 89
S Hacker attempts to poison water supply. Breaking News 0
N distilled water made heart race Water 11
R Sodium and water retention Ask For Help or Advice 5
Lenny Are "Crown Prince Natural, Whole Oysters, Packed In Water" Any good and freeze-able? Seafood 5
A What's The Proper Way Of Doing Water Fast? Ask For Help or Advice 16
N Can I Dissolve Caffeine Powder In Boiled Water And Then Apply On My Scalp? Hair & Nails 22
Harryedgar Peat Practice - Help Needed With Inflammation And Water Retention Ask For Help or Advice 4
R T3 During Water Fasting Ask For Help or Advice 6
Mito 4th Phase Water Could Heal Ecological Problems Miscellaneous Health Discussions 0
C Water Restriction / How Much Liquids Do You Get? Water 19
J Fluoride Content Of Sparkling Water An Issue? Water 10
Recoen Cowan And Pollack On Water Water 23
K Can I Use SAM-E Powder In Just Water? Mental Issues 3

Similar threads

Top