Harvard PUFA Sat Fat Study

forterpride

Member
Joined
Jun 7, 2013
Messages
160
Hello friends. I have been preaching to my father lately about the importance of reducing PUFA intake...and he emailed me this study which I am dumbfounded by. How do I respond to him when he just smiles and tells me Ray Peat is radical? If someone could tell me in laments terms how to debunk these findings, I would greatly appreciate it. Thanks guys!.

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/20 ... 211831.htm
 

jaguar43

Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2012
Messages
1,310
forterpride said:
Hello friends. I have been preaching to my father lately about the importance of reducing PUFA intake...and he emailed me this study which I am dumbfounded by. How do I respond to him when he just smiles and tells me Ray Peat is radical? If someone could tell me in laments terms how to debunk these findings, I would greatly appreciate it. Thanks guys!.

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/20 ... 211831.htm

in the study citations 21 and 23 actually promote decreasing pufa for CHD.
 
J

j.

Guest
The thing about convincing is hard. The strategy I use is telling people what I do if somebody asks, and mention the PUFA studies in rats accelerating their metabolism. And that that, added to my experiences with reducing PUFA, are enough for me to believe I should avoid PUFA.
 

MrMoose63

Member
Joined
Sep 15, 2012
Messages
23
In my opinion meta analysis studies are BS. Within statistical parameters (confidence intervals) you can generally make the data fit what ever you want. Also it seems like many of these studies are correlating CHD with cholesterol levels when cholesterol levels may be a better indicator for hypothyroidism.
 

Mittir

Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2013
Messages
2,034
I read some of the stuff Harvard's Mozaffarian group been writing on fat and heart disease.
I totally agree with what MrMooose said about meta-analysis. If they make any mistake they can always
blame it on others. They ( Harvard and American Heart Association) are recommending not only PUFA but also omega-6 . There is good amount of evidence that omega 6 is inflammatory. But they are saying that it is wrong to say omega 6 is inflammatory. Because derivative of omega-6 can be anti-inflammatory too.They are right about it. But they are not providing any data on to how much of the omega-6 converts to anti-inflammatory path. Then they are saying that production of arachidonic acid is tightly controlled and it does not matter how much omega-6 we eat. But i have read tons of studies that shows excess omega-6 increases inflammatory marker. They also do not buy the ratio of omega6- omega 3 affecting inflammation. If someone goes by brand name of Harvard it is hard to disprove them. They claim only a handful of scientists are claiming omega 6 is inflammatory. I am in total shock.
According to Ray Peat excess estrogen and serotonin promotes inflammatory pathway for omega-6
Chris Masterjohn has written a good review of Harvard study showing their flaws.
http://www.westonaprice.org/blogs/cmast ... -old-days/

Here is another study from 97 ,they did a review on same subject and found that low saturated fat diet does not promote heart health. They also criticized studies that claimed PUFA helps with heart disease.

http://eurheartj.oxfordjournals.org/con ... 8.full.pdf

You can check omega-6 page on wikipedia, it got some good info on omega 6 promoting lots of other diseases.
Most anti-inflammatory medicine blocks breakdown products of omega-6. Also check wiki page on pufa ratio and
oxidation of PUFA.
It is easier to convince someone to follow a very low fat diet with olive oil. This will minimize the exposure to PUFA.
There is too much 'evidence" against animal fat to convince someone unless they are willing to spend a good amount of time reading scientific studies.
 

Asimov

Member
Joined
Jan 19, 2013
Messages
162
It's impossible to refute the study without looking at the methods.

I mean, it was probably a lazy meta-analysis funded by someone from the grape seed oil industries. I always giggle when people think studies are irrefutable, profound science. I've spoken to many doctors who have told me, verbatim

"If you conduct a study that doesn't come up with the result the backer wants, you'll never be paid to conduct another study by anyone for the rest of your career"

Scientific jouranals and science daily specifically should be thought of more as a paid press release than actual objective analysis of data.
 

Beebop

Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2013
Messages
289
It's hard for people to get their heads around, that PUFA = bad. I think one of the things that turned people off SAFA was the idea that hard animal fats, solid at room temperature are clogging up arteries. I'm sure people develop a squeamish mental image of the evil hard fat inside their body, (even though of course at body temps all Sat fats are liquid, and beautifully stable.)

I like Peat's stories about the farmers that tried to fatten pigs with coconut oil and made them leaner. Then used anti-thyroid drugs to make them fat (and ill/toxic), and later found that corn oil had the same effect.

I tell people I care about: "coconut oil is amazing, protects your thyroid, and raises your metabolism, so it can help you lose weight". You can also explain how it's safer to fry with because it doesn't go rancid. Then I buy them some coconut oil.

Just some thoughts, not related to your study issue. Good luck!

p.s. for a good read on how scientific studies are manipulated read "Bad Science" by Ben Goldacre. Could be one for your dad.
 

Gabriel

Member
Joined
May 7, 2013
Messages
229
That metaanalysis is one of the worst on the field. stick to the work by christopher ramsden instead.
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
encerent Why Is Harvard Medical School Still Promoting Soybean Oil? Health 10
haidut Harvard Creates Batteries Using Quinones And Riboflavin Scientific Studies 6
tonto "Unsaturated Fats Linked To Longer Healthier Life" - Harvard Gazette Cholesterol 48
B Interview With Dr. Michael Hamblin: Harvard Professor and Infrared Therapy Expert Red Light, Infrared, LLLT 12
S Harvard Ivory Towers Are Going After Salt This Time Health 10
mandance Harvard urging people to not drink milk. Doubts About Milk 13
M Organic Milk Contains More PUFA? Diet 3
I 2004 patent for low PUFA eggs Dairy, Eggs 10
Atma Ray Peat Interview #30: LSD, Serotonin, and Hallucinations | PUFA and Lipofuscin | Strategy of Tension | William Blake Interviews 4
ursidae >70 g of PUFA a day | Does diet even matter? Diet 72
haidut PUFA is catabolic, SFA is anti-catabolic (anabolic) Scientific Studies 0
DANIEL Anti-Peat Peat Wrong About PUFA? Debate - Anti-Peat 46
G Which fish is best to eat in-terms of PUFA, Mercury? And maybe pollution, nuclear waste... Seafood 4
johnwester130 did my face change from k2 and avoiding PUFA? Health 84
lvysaur The Asian-Caucasoid PUFA dichotomy Scientific Studies 4
A PUFA (omega-7 Unsaturated Fatty Acids) Cause Of 'old People Smell' Polyunsaturated Fats, Seed Oils 3
Lokzo An Interview With Haidut (Georgi Dinkov) About PUFA's haidut 9
P Anti-Peat What Does Peat Have To Say About Tribal/indigenous Peoples Eating Pufa? Debate - Anti-Peat 22
A Pufa Detox - Vitamin E Polyunsaturated Fats, Seed Oils 6
Harryedgar Pufa Seems More Anabolic Than SAT Here - What Do Y’all Think? Polyunsaturated Fats, Seed Oils 4
johnwester130 Malassezia Turn Sebum Into PUFA - Is This Theory True? Hair & Nails 5
S Feeling Good After PUFA Polyunsaturated Fats, Seed Oils 5
haidut Dietary PUFA In Childhood Causes Diabetes And Irreversible (male) Infertility Scientific Studies 3
haidut PUFA Exacerbate, Saturated Fats (SFA) / Albumin / Calcium Ameliorate COVID-19 Scientific Studies 2
Razvan Pufa Deplition Is Amazing Mental Issues 22
Korven German Doctor Treats MS With Low PUFA Diet (Stops Disease In 84% Of Patients) Cancer, Degenerative Diseases 25
jamies33 Is Conjugated Linoleic Acid A PUFA? Milk 0
ecstatichamster Ray Peat Interview #35: CO2, Ketosis, And Mitochondria | PUFA, Sugar, Iron, And AGEs | Progesterone And Cell Stabil Danny Roddy 21
Harryedgar Fat Loss, PUFA, Estrogen Detox And Increased Metabolism Weight 0
haidut Dietary PUFA Causes (reversible) Male Infertility And Androgen Deficiency Scientific Studies 4
N Anti-Peat Saturated Fat TERRIBLE For Liver Health & Diabetes. Compared To PUFA Debate - Anti-Peat 140
lyfe Does Conventional Milk Contain PUFA? Diet 4
koreus Tearful After Reducing Stress And Cortisol By Removing PUFA Cortisol, Serotonin, Histamine 11
D Firebrand Meats - Low PUFA Pork Meat 5
D Low Pufa, Plant Based + Lean Wild Meat? Better Metabolism? Diet 10
N PUFA Chart? Ask For Help or Advice 4
wealthofwisdom What Specific PUFA Foods Did You Remove From Your Diet? Diet 49
L PUFA Detox? Metabolism 3
T Is There Are An Effective Way Clean PUFA Oil From Canned Oysters? Meat, Organ Meat, Gelatin, Seafood 5
J Why Does Peat Say Beef Is Low PUFA? Studies Are Contrary. I Don't Get It Meat 6
haidut PUFA Are Toxic/carcinogenic, And That Has Been Known For Decades Scientific Studies 5
haidut Striking Accumulation Of PUFA In Aged Cells Scientific Studies 10
haidut PUFA May Be A Major Factor In Sterility Scientific Studies 0
haidut PUFA Increases Risk Of All Cancers, Especially Prostate Scientific Studies 0
haidut Diet (PUFA) Causes Inflammatory Bowel Disease (IBD) Scientific Studies 0
haidut PUFA Is A Cancer "sensitizer" Scientific Studies 0
haidut PUFA Makes Girls Fat / Lazy / Diabetic And Exercise Futile Scientific Studies 13
haidut Nut (PUFA) Consumption May Cause Diabetes Even Without Obesity Scientific Studies 0
haidut PUFA Increases Risks Of Skin Cancers Scientific Studies 0
haidut PUFA May Drive Obesity, Insulin Resistance, Liver Issues In Diabetes II Patients Scientific Studies 0

Similar threads

Top