Even "non-carcinogenic" estrogens can cause cancer


Mar 18, 2013
USA / Europe
I know, the title is a "paradox", but this is truly what the article discusses. By now, we already know that the word "paradox" in science is just a euphemism for idotism and/or fraud. Apparently, mainstream medicine has managed to convinced the public somehow that there are carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic estrogens. An example of the former would be (17)-beta-estradiol and an example of the latter would be (17)-alpha-estradiol. The former is a strong agonist/activator of both estrogen receptors while the latter binds and interacts with those receptors very weakly. That is precisely the reason, medicine has been claiming that alpha-estradiol is non-carcinogenic. While beta-estradol has been officially labelled a "known carcinogen" by the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences (NIEHS), which is a part of the National Institutes of Health (NIH) and as such Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), the alpha isomer has not. Now, the article is almost 17 years old and many things have changed since then. Namely, mainstream medicine has completely ignored the NIEHS announcement and has also been staging attacks on the results of the WHI studies that demonstrated beta-estradiol causes cancer, heart disease, strokes, dementia, etc. So, 17 years after the (still standing) official classification of estrogen as a carcinogen by the very "experts" we are all told to obey, the new position of those same experts is that neither the beta nor the alpha isomers of estradiol are carcinogenic. One of the main justifications given for the renewed promotion of estrogen is that it acts as an "antioxidant", yet the study below found the exact opposite - estrogen, by itself, can cause oxidative stress that is crucial for carcinogenesis. To me, at least, the evidence is quite clear and in plain sight - there is no such thing as a safe estrogen! Especially, in the presence of PUFA, which amplifies estrogen's genomic/receptor effects and also increases oxidative stress.


"...It's disconcerting to think that a natural hormone circulating in significant amounts through the bodies of half the world's population is a carcinogen, but it's now official. In December, the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences (NIEHS) added estrogen to its list of known cancer-causing agents. For years, estrogen has been a suspected carcinogen, since strong epidemiological evidence associates the hormone to breast, endometrial, and uterine cancers. Women who begin menstruating early, or who start menopause late, produce more estrogen over their lifetimes and have a higher risk of breast cancer. Recently, the clinical trial of estrogen plus progestin treatment therapy was terminated because of an increased risk of breast cancer."

"...To see if cancer-causing estrogens need oxygen radicals to produce tumors, Bhat implanted pellets of the hormone in hamsters that are susceptible to estrogen-induced kidney cancer. This model is widely used as an animal model of hormonal cancer. As expected, when the carcinogenic 17beta-estradiol (E2) was used, nearly all hamsters with the pellets developed cancer within seven months. E2 promotes cell proliferation and produces oxygen radicals when metabolized by the cell."

"...Also, as expected, none of the hamsters developed kidney cancer when a non-carcinogenic estrogen, 17-alpha-ethinyl-estradiol (EE) was implanted. EE acts through estrogen receptors to create new cells like E2, but unlike E2, is poorly broken down and does not produce oxygen radicals. But when EE was combined with a non-estrogen molecule that generates oxygen radicals, 30 percent of the hamsters developed kidney cancer within seven months."

"...But it also suggests that reputedly "safe" estrogens that are touted as replacements for the estrogens in hormone replacement therapy may not be so safe after all. "If we have oxidative stress in cells from other chemicals, then women are at risk for cancer even with estrogens that are considered non-carcinogenic," Bhat says. "The therapy may be safer if taken with antioxidants, but more research is needed to make safe and more effective antioxidants."
Last edited:
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
S Non-Hegelian Marxism Political Talk, Alternative World Theories 5
K Non-toxic Cookware Ask For Help or Advice 0
T Non Electronic Beard Trimmer Body Care 11
J Exercise diverts calories away from non-productive uses like excessive inflammation? Exercise 1
J Found the best non toxic mattresses in the UK Insomnia, Sleep Issues 1
L Does a Moderna vaccinated person cause harm to a non vaccinated person? Vaccines 15
J Is it important to get a good quality organic/non toxic bed mattress? Body Care 1
Mito The efficacy of vitamin E in reducing non-alcoholic fatty liver disease E 0
boris Children (non Infectious, 0% Death Rate) Are Harmed For Life By Social Distancing And Isolation Mind, Sleep, Stress 9
Mr Joe How To Deal With Non-Peatarian People : COVID 19 Viruses, Parasites, Fungus, Vaccines 0
S Best Non Dairy And Non Supplement Ways To Get Calcium? Digestion 18
Recoen Metabolic Acidosis - Anion Vs Non Anion Gap Acidity vs. Alkalinity 4
L The Association Of Sex Steroid Hormone Concentrations With Non-alcoholic Fatty Liver Disease And Liv Scientific Studies 0
Tristan Loscha Metabolomics Study Reveals Differences Between Diabetic And Non‐diabetic Patients With Cataract Eyes, Ears, Nose and Headaches/Migraines 0
haidut Simple, Non-invasive Test For Adrogenic / Estrogenic Tone Scientific Studies 8
L Non Stop Salivating? Oral Health 1
wealthofwisdom Non-Milk Calcium Sources? Diet 14
Amazoniac Conceptualization Of The ETS Is Chain'd To The Past: A Non-linear Model Converging On Ubiquinode Articles & Scientific Studies 2
M Fullerene-C60 Non-toxic Antioxidant 100–1000 Times More Active Than Vitamin E Supplements, Pharmaceutical Drugs 3
Nicolas Noyola Is Fermented Milk [yogurt] A Better Choice For Non-Europeans ? Dairy 2
M Non-Bacterial Prostatitis Ask For Help or Advice 2
E Scientific Evidence Non-ionizing Radiation From Mobile Phones Has Mental And Biological Effects Society 0
ScurveDream What Is The Bioenergetic/"Peaty" Approach To Non-senescence (or Reverse/anti-aging)? Ask For Help or Advice 0
A What's The Non-bacterial Cause Of Gut Bloating?stay Awak Ask For Help or Advice 8
Francisco Organic OJ Concentrate Or Non-Organic Pure OJ Ask For Help or Advice 0
I Interesting Non-Conformists: Peace Pilgrim Society 1
haidut Statins More Than Double The Risk Of Diabetes Compared To Non-users Scientific Studies 0
olive Gelatin Enhances Non-gene Iron Uptake, Glycine Does Not Scientific Studies 3
mayweatherking Rate This Non Dairy Diet Diet 7
B Estrogen In Contained In Non Grass-fed, Inorganic Beef Diet 1
Amazoniac The Non-slippery Hand: Fingers Wrinkling From Water Might Be Intentional Symptoms, Causes 1
cyclops Recommended Solution To Dissolve Steroid Powders? (Non-DMSO) Supplements, Pharmaceutical Drugs 19
Queequeg Eggs Non-detrimental To Endothelial Function And Serum Lipids Scientific Studies 3
Nicolas Noyola Sulfated Steroids Are Higher In Healthier People; Non-Sulfated Steroids Lower Blood Work, Labs 1
Gadsie Should I Stay In A Non-peat Relationship Ask For Help or Advice 48
J Non EMF Headphones For New IPhone (damn Apple) Ask For Help or Advice 4
T Tropical Vs. Non-Tropical Fruit Fruits 3
jamies33 Healthy Peaty Smokers - Would You Recommend Smoking To Non-smokers? Alcohol, Tobacco, Drugs 29
Zpol "The Cell: " By Joshua Z. Rappoport - Explains How Cells Work For Us Non-chemistry Peeps Articles & Scientific Studies 3
vulture Best Way Of Eating Non-Peat To Bulk Up? Diet, Recipes 19
I Options When Non-Fat Milk Is Unavailable Ask For Help or Advice 0
W "Fructan, Rather Than Gluten, Induces Symptoms In Patients With Non-celiac Gluten Sensitivity" Scientific Studies 6
RedStaR The Non-Ray Peat Thread The Ray Peat Forum Lounge 13
W Gbolduev Q And A - Non Peat Gbolduev 1425
G Is Store Bought Non Organic Orange Juice Okay? Fruits & Fruit Juice 8
F Ray Peat's Thesis: William Blake And The Mysticisms Of Sense And Non-Sense (Available For Download) Articles & Newsletters Discussion 40
K Coconut Cream And Looking For A Non-estrogenic Thickening Agent And Squash Diet 0
Drareg Blue Zone VEGAN Diet And Non Existent Sperm Quality Scientific Studies 5
R Cellular Stress In The Brain May Contribute To Non-alcoholic Fatty Liver Disease Scientific Studies 0
B Non Detectable Levels Of Insulin And Normal Glucose Levels Health 0

Similar threads