There Is No "Depression Gene", Any "evidence" So Far Has Been Errors / Fraud


Mar 18, 2013
USA / Europe
I did not think that I would see such a brave post appear on the front page of "Science" magazine, but here it is below. Apparently, common sense is finally starting to prevail in psychiatry and some doctors have had enough with the whole genetics fraud. They published a paper arguing that not only there is no evidence for a "depression gene" but even genome-wide interaction explanations are baseless and have no evidence behind them. As the authors of the post says in the comments, the "publish or perish" dogma has essentially ensured that the vast majority of publications are simply junk driven by aggressive funding deadlines and overzealous PIs. Finally, as the authors says, some people are turning their efforts onto affecting enzymes related to brain function, and that is "not a stupid idea". No kidding!
How many more need to commit suicide or suffer for decades from a mental disorder before the public (and doctors) finally open their eyes??

Psychiatry Online
Decades Of Research About Depression Could Be Wrong

"...I wrote a couple of years ago about the long-running study of mutations in a serotonin transporter gene. Over the years, polymorphism in the gene have been correlated with all sorts of human behavior and psychiatry, in keeping with the importance of serotonin signaling in human cognition. Depression, anxiety, that whole end of human behavior seemed to be affected by just what sort of genetic variation one had. Hundreds and hundreds of studies have appeared in the literature, many of them with truly impressive p-values. Well, as that old post shows, people have been throwing cold water on this idea for a while now as well, and now there’s a paper that should (you’d think) expunge the whole idea of 5-HTTLPR variations having anything coherent to tell us about human disease. It doesn’t stop there: the authors go on to demolish every other “depression gene” connection in the existing literature. They went after the lot:"

"...Utilizing data from large population-based and case-control samples (Ns ranging from 62,138 to 443,264 across subsamples), the authors conducted a series of preregistered analyses examining candidate gene polymorphism main effects, polymorphism-by-environment interactions, and gene-level effects across a number of operational definitions of depression (e.g., lifetime diagnosis, current severity, episode recurrence) and environmental moderators (e.g., sexual or physical abuse during childhood, socioeconomic adversity)."

"...Nothing. No clear evidence for any given gene, in any polymorphic form, with any effect on depression, as either measured by itself or in combination with any other environmental effect. At this point it seems safe to say that there are no single standout genes that can be associated with depression. That’s not to say that there’s no genetic influence at all, but what this means is that (like so many other things) it’s a complex mix of dozens, hundreds, thousands of genetic factors tangled with environmental ones. It may well be that many of these end up binning into similar phenotypes or heading down common pathways, but we don’t know that for sure, either. What we do know is that talk of a “depression gene” is nonsense."

"...Looking back, the single biggest problem with all these earlier proposals (and there have been plenty) is that their sample sizes were wildly, hilariously small. Once again, it’s all down to effect size. The paper calculates that the largest-effect-size gene candidates in this field would still need samples in the tens of thousands to detect. And what has the median sample size been over the years? 345 patients. Right. This literature is all noise, all false positives, all junk. As you actually move to larger and larger studies, everything disappears, which is what noise does. Real stuff, on the other hand, should become stronger and harder to ignore as you increase the N, with tighter error bars and better signal/noise."

"...He goes on to note that there are a number of diagnostic tests that are supposed to helppractitioners prescribe antidepressants based on gene sequence. But work like this latest paper strongly suggests that this is not well-founded. Some of these tests are for metabolic enzyme isoforms that could affect blood levels of specific compoundsand that’s not a stupid idea, although it’s often harder to realize in practice than just doing a sequence on someone. But there are companies using the exact same genes whose connection to depression is being invalidated. Slate Star Codex again: "

"...So far, there appears to be little or no reliable evidence that such testing is useful. That’s not to say that it can’t ever be, just that the people who are trying to sell it to you right now don’t have a very strong case. Psychiatric indications, out of the entire landscape of medical therapy, are really the most difficult and treacherous region to try to navigate with any sorts of molecule-level explanations. We don’t know enough to get that granular. We really don’t. If you start digging into the details of depression, anxiety, OCD, bipolar disorder and all the rest, the molecular and cellular-level explanations start coming apart in your hands like wet tissue paper. The field is littered with failed hypotheses, with just-so stories and compelling-but-wrong correlations, and with sources of unreliable data ranging from big, expensive, and completely honest efforts all the way down to plenty of outright charlatanry. Caveat emptor, and how."
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
Mauritio What you can do about quarantine induced social isolation and depression : Allopregnanolone! Scientific Studies 49
A Studies to convince Dr to prescribe Minocyline for depression/anxiety?? Mental Issues 0
T Drinking alcohol, depression not caring. Mental Issues 30
G Starting Caffeine - Lots of Health Problems - Asthma, Erectile Dysfunction, Hypertonic Pelvic Floor, Hair Loss, Anxiety/Depression Caffeine 54
haidut Niacinamide may treat depression by improving energetic state Scientific Studies 8
haidut Vitamin D prevents cortisol-induced depression and...inflammation Scientific Studies 0
xetawaves Anxiety, Depression And Confusion After Eating Ask For Help or Advice 6
F Help With "transitional" Depression Mental Issues 9
Infarouge Excellent Deep Dive Into Neurosteroids And Depression Hormones 1
T Sick Of The Depression And Anxiety Mental Issues 18
R My Brother With Psoriases And Depression, Helpp Metabolism 34
I Burn Out, Anxiety, Depression Mental Issues 29
S Depression After Working Out / Overworking At Work Experiments 0
haidut A Third Of Americans Show Signs Of Clinical Anxiety, Depression Scientific Studies 2
haidut Ketamine Cures Depression By Reducing Serotonin, Increasing Dopamine Scientific Studies 20
haidut SSRI Drugs, Not Depression, Destroy Empathy Scientific Studies 0
haidut The Government Knows Stress Causes "learned Helplessness" / Depression Scientific Studies 2
GutFeeling Dietary Eggs Prevents And Alleviate Depression Scientific Studies 0
S Lipopolysaccharide-Induced Depression-Like Behaviors Is Ameliorated By Sodium Butyrate Via Inhibitin Scientific Studies 0
A Donald Trump And The Great Depression 2.0. Herbert Hoover? Ask For Help or Advice 0
W Niacinamide And Depression B3/Niacinamide 19
L Nicotinamide Mononucleotide Ameliorates The Depression-like Behaviors And Is Associated With Attenua B3/Niacinamide 0
S Glass Of Wine And Depression Health 1
A Any Conjectures On The Connection Between Beta Blockers And Depression? Ask For Help or Advice 0
J Inducing Mild Fever Helps Depression Scientific Studies 2
bzmazu Aspirin Can Battle Depression. Supplements, Pharmaceutical Drugs 0
M Food Without Enough Salt: Complete Depression, With Salt: Feels Great Diet 16
theLaw #10: Scientism, Serotonin, Autism, Toxic Excipients, Depression W/ Georgi Dinkov & Jahed Momand Danny Roddy 26
haidut Vast Majority (90%) Of Depression Cases Are Caused By Stress Scientific Studies 2
H #05: Bioenergetic News And Q&A - Global Warming, Serotonin, Dopamine, Nitric Oxide, Depression, BPA Miscellaneous Health Discussions 16
P Higher Altitude - Greater Depression/Suicide Mental Issues 27
Dan Wich KMUD: 6-21-2019 Postpartum Depression KMUD Radio-The Herb Doctors 17
ecstatichamster May 2019 Postpartum Depression, Brain, Aging And Reductionism Articles & Newsletters 3
D What I Do To Ward Off Stress - Anciety - "Depression" Mental Issues 16
haidut Endotoxin (LPS) May Cause Depression / Anhedonia Scientific Studies 31
L After 20 Years And Untold $ Studying Serotonin-linked Genes, No Actual Depression Link Articles & Scientific Studies 0
K Can You Guys Help Out Please? Severe Social Anxiety And Refractory Depression Mental Issues 17
haidut Cortisol (stress) Directly Causes Depression Scientific Studies 25
H Hormonal Blood Tests I Got For Depression Blood Work, Labs 14
Alex Jaramillo Morning Routine To Fight Depression Mental Issues 0
ecstatichamster What Cured Your Depression? Mental Issues 107
haidut Depression Rates Rising, Most Strikingly In Teens And Millenials Scientific Studies 84
GAF New-drug-hopes-reversing-memory-loss-old-age-depression-schizophrenia-alzheimers Alzheimer's 3
ken Salt And Depression Sodium 1
ddjd High Nitric Oxide As The Cause For Mental Illness/depression Ask For Help or Advice 10
L Anemoside A3 Rapidly Reverses Depression-like Behaviors And Weakening Of Excitatory Synaptic Transmi Supplements 0
isabella83 Depression, Melatonin, Wifi, Oh My Mental Issues 59
M ED, Isotretinoin (accutane) And Mild Depression Male Issues 3
L Minocycline For Depression: A Systematic Review And Meta-analysis Of Clinical Trials Scientific Studies 13
VendettaRed911 Weight Loss And Depression Diet 2

Similar threads