What Do You Think Of Metabolic Typing?

Ryan999

Member
Joined
Oct 8, 2012
Messages
48
I was just reading an article by Paul Check about the variation in the anatomy of humans and how that effects what diets are optimal for humans. Basically people near the equator do better on higher carbohydrate diets, people near the poles and from Europe do better on higher protein/fat diets, and mixed races have a bit of a mixed diet. People near the equator in some instances had literally double the distance from mouth to anus as people near the poles.

I'm Irish (so I guess a protein/fat type) and I can identify with this very well. If I have too many carbs and not enough protein/fat I'm the most irritable person in the world an hour later and I haven't been able to figure it out. I need meat/eggs at almost every meal to feel satisfied and now it makes a lot of sense. A lot of times I would try meals of cheese and OJ and would be miserable.

Can anyone relate to this? Is there anything to this?

*I just want to add I'm not discrediting Peat at all, just bringing up the fact that there might be a lot of variation within the Peat diet as far as macronutrient ratios are concernced, and this isn't talked about enough.
 

gretchen

Member
Joined
Nov 30, 2012
Messages
816
I spent about a decade involved with blood typing, so no, I would not do metabolic type. I've found that that typing systems aren't very scientific.
 

Combie

Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2012
Messages
293
Age
43
Location
UK
The biggest problem i have with metabolic typing, apart from prescribing a perfect diet based on a questionnaire, is that your metabolic type can change. Doesnt that show that theres no such thing as a metabolic type? I think the reason northerners do better initially on protein and fats is to do with glucose clearance. Most northern folk are better off starting with more fats simply because they have adapted to relatively low carb diets and their ability to handle glucose reflects that. Once you slowly start to up the carbs, you are going to be able to handle it better, and become a "mixed" or "carbo" type. Of course, the book by walcott is designed to sell. So they call it a "protein type" when its really a "fat type", (because the mainstream are scared of fat), and do not allow sugar (because theyre all scared of sugar too) pretty much at all. We all know that fructose (and fat) is the key player in handling your blood sugar properly, and if you use sugar instead of starches, you will progress to being a "carbo type" much more quickly.

Bunk
 

yerrag

Member
Joined
Mar 29, 2016
Messages
6,501
Location
Manila
Resurrecting an old thread, I benefited from using metabolic typing, even as now I realize its foundation is very much based on empirical data and not so much on understanding human physiology on a deeper level. Having read up (and continuing to do so) on Ray Peat, I can appreciate why there would appear to be metabolic types, and why metabolic types can change into the "balanced type" after taking the right steps.

I don't consider metabolic typing to be bunk. By classifying people into types, it makes it easier for people to understand where they are, and the food and supplements prescribed for them are much easier to follow. They do not have to know why they are the way they are, and why such a food or supplement is better suited for them. Given the confusing landscape in which health and nutrition resides, it is easier for a novice to navigate the waters with simple classifications. Consider that there are practically no doctors whom you can see that practice along the lines of Ray Peat's thinking, it is very much left to the person to read up and apply his principles. It is a daunting task, not recommended for the average person.

In the end, what counts is whether our body reaches a state of homeostatis, which is what health is about.

Certainly, Ray Peat is superior. I did not learn about how unhealthful PUFAs are with metabolic typing.
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
M Metabolic Typing. Dr Kelly Ask For Help or Advice 3
Mito Vitamin D Supplementation Ameliorates Metabolic Dysfunction in Patients with PCOS D 0
Hgreen56 Does Gaba decrease metabolic rate? Diet 0
A Chronic Fatigue Syndrome is a metabolic disorder Metabolism 55
TopGun1911 Did I permanently alter my metabolic and hormonal function by going on keto for 3 months + fasting? Diet 21
haidut Glaucoma likely a metabolic disease, treatable by pyruvate and/or niacinamide Scientific Studies 0
A Metabolic Side Effects Of Fluoride (a Halogen) Improved With Tamarind Leaf Thyroid and Hormones 0
PaintedPony New Here And Would Welcome Metabolic Advice Metabolism 4
Mito The Metabolic, Neuroprotective Cardioprotective And Antitumor Effects Of The Klotho Protein Articles & Scientific Studies 7
A Hypothyroidism Is Naturally Induced Chemo Therapy. Every Metabolic Stressor Is A Carcinogenic Miscellaneous Health Discussions 13
B Crickets Fed Low Dose Aspirin Live 143% Longer, Have Longer Childhoods And Higher Metabolic Rates Scientific Studies 7
Recoen Metabolic Acidosis - Anion Vs Non Anion Gap Acidity vs. Alkalinity 4
haidut Simple Metabolic Change Sufficient To Turn "normal" Cells Into "cancer" Scientific Studies 3
S My Taste In Music Changes With Metabolic State Ask For Help or Advice 24
meatbag Women’s Egg Quality Dependent On Metabolic Factors Scientific Studies 1
Randle Cyclist Cannabis: Pro Or Anti-metabolic? Alcohol, Tobacco, Drugs 73
noqcks Cancer Is A Metabolic Disease Blogs 5
haidut Mad Cow Disease May Be A Mitochondrial/metabolic Issue Scientific Studies 2
Mito COVID-19 And Metabolic Syndrome – An Association Too DIfficult To Ignore Articles & Scientific Studies 1
Pdohlen Roche Mapping Metabolic Pathway Articles & Scientific Studies 0
D Peripheral Thyroid Conversion And Its Impact On TSH And Metabolic Activity Scientific Studies 1
Ras Metabolic Compound Could Rewind Fertility Clock For Women (Niacin) Vitamins 0
milkboi Discipline: Is It Necessarily Serotonergic/Anti-Metabolic? Stress 2
Chris-R Hypo-metabolic Yet Hyper And Anxious? + T3 & Peating Experiments 1
R Soybean Oil Linked To Metabolic And Neurological Changes In Mice Scientific Studies 1
haidut Metabolic Dysfunction Is A Primary Cause Of Aging And Its Symptom Alzheimer Disease (AD) Scientific Studies 3
Mito Metabolic Effects Of A Prolonged, Very-high-dose Dietary Fructose Challenge In Healthy Subjects Scientific Studies 11
haidut Progesterone May Treat Diabetes, Obesity, And Metabolic Syndrome Scientific Studies 6
Tristan Loscha Magnesium Retention From Metabolic-Balance Studies In Female Adolescents: Impact Of NaCl Articles & Scientific Studies 0
ecstatichamster Salt Restriction Lowers Metabolic Rate And Increases Fat Articles & Scientific Studies 2
D Any Tests To Demonstrate Metabolic Function? Metabolism 1
yerrag Why Do We Accept Age As The Defining Factor For Metabolic Rate? Metabolism 3
methylenewhite Sustained Release DNP Made At Yale Treats NAFLD, Diabetes II And Other Metabolic Abnormalities Scientific Studies 0
_lppaiva Cake As A Metabolic Food? Recipes 18
L Metabolic State Crucial To Immunotherapy-effectiveness Cancer 10
Kingpinguin Could Someone Explain How Inflammation Causes Diabetes (metabolic Disease) On Cell Level Metabolism 7
L Neuroendocrine And Immune Disequilibrium As A Probable Link Between Metabolic Syndrome And Carcinoge Articles & Scientific Studies 2
Amazoniac The Skin Function: A Factor Of Anti-metabolic Syndrome Skin 6
Inaut Sugar, Dairy & Metabolic Health W/ Danny Roddy Danny Roddy 38
Hans Breakfast Skippers Might Be At Higher Risk Of Metabolic Inflexibility And Inflammation Scientific Studies 21
JanP Could The Caffeine Slow Down Metabolic Rate, When Calories Are Not Abundant? Ask For Help or Advice 1
R Dietary Carbohydrate Restriction Improves Metabolic Syndrome Independent Of Weight Loss Scientific Studies 2
haidut (Brain) Cancer Is A Metabolic Disease, Can Be Treated By Glutamine Restriction Scientific Studies 6
haidut Cancer Is A Metabolic Disease, Diet Is Its Drug Scientific Studies 47
Lokzo Role Of Dietary Histidine In The Prevention Of Obesity And Metabolic Syndrome Scientific Studies 6
A Theory: Sugar Is A Metabolic 'activator', Works Well If Body Has Enough Nutrients Ray Peat Topics 65
methylenewhite Pro-metabolic Peat Inspired Community/healing Center In Mexico Miscellaneous 0
Hans Methylene Blue Inhibits Fatty Acid Oxidation And Improve Metabolic Flexibility In The Heart Supplements, Pharmaceutical Drugs 0
Cameron Has Anyone Noticed Increased Mood Metabolic Benefits From Aspirin Ask For Help or Advice 8
debored13 Metabolic Trap In ME/CFS Scientific Studies 24

Similar threads

Top