The Government Knows Stress Causes "learned Helplessness" / Depression

haidut

Member
Joined
Mar 18, 2013
Messages
17,320
Location
USA / Europe
I have had discussions with numerous psychiatrists about the concept of "learned helplessness" (LH) and its relation to chronic stress. All of those doctors flatly denied that LH is a concept relevant to humans and argued that it is nothing more than a useful model of depression in animal studies, designed to evaluate animal exposure to chronic stress. Those doctors were even more agitated in their denials of applicability of LH or chronic stress to human mental health disorders due to the purported significant genetic component of such diseases, which makes stress alone an insufficient explanation/cause. Well, apparently the model of human psychiatric conditions used by government agencies for military purposes is quite different from the one used by civilian psychiatrists. As the articles below demonstrate, the government designed the "enhanced interrogation techniques" (aka torture) with the explicit goal of inducing a state of LH/depression in the enemy combatants through the application of inescapable, chronic stress. The military and intelligence agencies apparently use theories of human mental health that do not even mention genetics and to the best of my knowledge none of the enemy combatants were genetically profiled for vulnerability to depression. The irony of the story is that some of the most secretive, and closed-minded organizations in the world are apparently a lot more open and progressive in regards to environmental influence on mental health than are the authors of the (in)famous DSM.

https://www.amnestyusa.org/pdfs/sscistudy1.pdf
"..."Learned helplessness" in this context was the theory that detainees might become passive and depressed in response to adverse or uncontrollable events, and would thus cooperate and provide information."

Out of the Darkness
"...Mitchell and Jessen were interested in applying the psychological concept of “learned helplessness” to interrogation. Psychologist Martin Seligman pioneered studies on the phenomenon in experiments he conducted on dogs in the 1960s. Seligman used the term “learned helplessness” to describe the state of utter passivity prompted by a series of negative events that leads subjects to believe there is nothing they can do to escape their suffering. Seligman conducted his experiments by administering electric shocks to different groups of dogs. When given the chance to avoid their pain, the dogs in his experiment that had been able to escape the shocks did so quickly. Those that couldn’t stop the pain didn’t even try to avoid it, even when given the opportunity. They believed they had no ability to control their fates. They had learned helplessness."

"...Mitchell and Jessen posited that this theory could be applied to interrogation — that harsh measures could be used to break any resistance of al-Qaida captives by inducing a state of learned helplessness. Torture would “shape compliance” with interrogation, Mitchell and Jessen theorized. Once detainees were abused to the point of learned helplessness, resistance would crumble, and the detainees would divulge information that they might otherwise withhold."

Enhanced interrogation techniques - Wikipedia
"...The psychologists relied heavily on experiments done by American psychologist Martin Seligman in the 1970s on learned helplessness.[87] In these experiments caged dogs were exposed to severe electric shocks in a random way in order to completely break their will to resist.[87] Mitchell and Jessen applied this idea to the interrogation of Abu Zubaydah.[71][87] Many of the interrogation techniques used in the SERE program, including waterboarding, cold cell, long-time standing, and sleep deprivation were previously considered illegal under U.S. and international law and treaties at the time of Abu Zubaydah's capture.[88][89]"
 

Gone Peating

Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2018
Messages
890
It’s very intuitive and seems like common sense to me.

Only today’s hyper-rationalistic people would not see the obvious connection. It’s also weird that scientists hold that we are just advanced monkeys, yet pick and choose when to hold that view and when to hold that we are “special”

Most scientists are poor at logic
 

Regina

Member
Joined
Aug 17, 2016
Messages
3,068
Location
Chicago
I have had discussions with numerous psychiatrists about the concept of "learned helplessness" (LH) and its relation to chronic stress. All of those doctors flatly denied that LH is a concept relevant to humans and argued that it is nothing more than a useful model of depression in animal studies, designed to evaluate animal exposure to chronic stress. Those doctors were even more agitated in their denials of applicability of LH or chronic stress to human mental health disorders due to the purported significant genetic component of such diseases, which makes stress alone an insufficient explanation/cause. Well, apparently the model of human psychiatric conditions used by government agencies for military purposes is quite different from the one used by civilian psychiatrists. As the articles below demonstrate, the government designed the "enhanced interrogation techniques" (aka torture) with the explicit goal of inducing a state of LH/depression in the enemy combatants through the application of inescapable, chronic stress. The military and intelligence agencies apparently use theories of human mental health that do not even mention genetics and to the best of my knowledge none of the enemy combatants were genetically profiled for vulnerability to depression. The irony of the story is that some of the most secretive, and closed-minded organizations in the world are apparently a lot more open and progressive in regards to environmental influence on mental health than are the authors of the (in)famous DSM.

https://www.amnestyusa.org/pdfs/sscistudy1.pdf
"..."Learned helplessness" in this context was the theory that detainees might become passive and depressed in response to adverse or uncontrollable events, and would thus cooperate and provide information."

Out of the Darkness
"...Mitchell and Jessen were interested in applying the psychological concept of “learned helplessness” to interrogation. Psychologist Martin Seligman pioneered studies on the phenomenon in experiments he conducted on dogs in the 1960s. Seligman used the term “learned helplessness” to describe the state of utter passivity prompted by a series of negative events that leads subjects to believe there is nothing they can do to escape their suffering. Seligman conducted his experiments by administering electric shocks to different groups of dogs. When given the chance to avoid their pain, the dogs in his experiment that had been able to escape the shocks did so quickly. Those that couldn’t stop the pain didn’t even try to avoid it, even when given the opportunity. They believed they had no ability to control their fates. They had learned helplessness."

"...Mitchell and Jessen posited that this theory could be applied to interrogation — that harsh measures could be used to break any resistance of al-Qaida captives by inducing a state of learned helplessness. Torture would “shape compliance” with interrogation, Mitchell and Jessen theorized. Once detainees were abused to the point of learned helplessness, resistance would crumble, and the detainees would divulge information that they might otherwise withhold."

Enhanced interrogation techniques - Wikipedia
"...The psychologists relied heavily on experiments done by American psychologist Martin Seligman in the 1970s on learned helplessness.[87] In these experiments caged dogs were exposed to severe electric shocks in a random way in order to completely break their will to resist.[87] Mitchell and Jessen applied this idea to the interrogation of Abu Zubaydah.[71][87] Many of the interrogation techniques used in the SERE program, including waterboarding, cold cell, long-time standing, and sleep deprivation were previously considered illegal under U.S. and international law and treaties at the time of Abu Zubaydah's capture.[88][89]"
Thanks for these. Very interesting that the different models of thought between military and civilian health application. Almost as if.
Well, they have a large sample of detainees now.
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
Giraffe No government can withstand a challenge of 3.5% of its population. Political Talk, Alternative World Theories 15
M UK Government Paid £220m To Build Emergency Hospitals That Treated 200 Society 0
lvysaur US Government Putting Hidden Surveillance Cameras In Residential Areas Political Talk, Alternative World Theories 3
Drareg US Government Give 1.16 Billion To GAVI Vaccine Alliance Articles & Scientific Studies 0
tankasnowgod All Cause Mortality During COVID 19 Is Likely Signature Of Mass Homicide By Government Response Scientific Studies 22
E Uk Government Controlled 'Persuasion' Society 1
Giraffe Appeal Against A World Government Beyond All Control Political Talk, Alternative World Theories 45
burtlancast US Government Scared To Death Of Vit C Treatment By I.V. For Coronavirus Miscellaneous Health Discussions 3
meatbag German Military And Government Receive Different Vaccine Political Talk, Alternative World Theories 2
RealNeat What If The Government Does Actually Care About Us And Wants To Save Lives? Society 2
charlie RFK Jr. Wins Case Against U.S. Government For Vaccine Safety Violations Vaccines 7
haidut Serotonin Creates Obedient Zombies - The Ultimate Government Wet Dream Scientific Studies 89
haidut US Government Study Found Cellphones (EMF) Cause Brain And Heart Cancer Scientific Studies 0
L Why The Government Thinks Guinea Pigs Are More Important Than People C 3
E Received Iodine Pills From The Government The Ray Peat Forum Lounge 17
Badger Government Database On How Much Pharmas Are Paying Your Doctor Miscellaneous 5
bodacious Interview With Ray Peat On Government, Libertarianism, And Social Class Written Interviews 110
Drareg Which Government System Is The Best For People's Wealth? Political Talk, Alternative World Theories 54
sweetly UK government wants to tax sugar and reduce consumption The Ray Peat Forum Lounge 4
sweetly Australian Government Forces Parents To Vaccinate Their Children Or Have Their Benefits Taken Away Children 0
G New government dietary guidelines Discussing Dietary Models 0
G 1960s Government Subliminal National Anthem Video — It's TH Political Talk, Alternative World Theories 3
Lokzo Anti-Diabetic Herb No One Knows About Scientific Studies 0
G John McAfee At 74, Smokes And Drinks Everyday, Claims He's The Healthiest Man He Knows Miscellaneous Health Discussions 8
B Is Nobody Gonna Point Out The Elephant In The Room? Georgi Dinki Knows It All But He’s Still Fat? Ask For Help or Advice 372
E Ray Seems Like The Only Person That Knows Serotonin Is Not All That Rant or Rave 19
nigma No Researcher Knows So Much About Iodine And Human Evolution As The Italian Dr Sebastiano Venturi Minerals 32
P Anyone Knows This Study Ray Mentioned In His Articles? Ask For Help or Advice 4
Dessert_All_Day Google Is Super Secretive About Its Anti-aging Research. No One Knows Why Articles & Scientific Studies 24
S Life Knows, Life Finds a Way Articles & Scientific Studies 0
N How do I increase my stress tolerance? Health 0
S Anti-Peat Stress Hormones in Context Debate - Anti-Peat 15
haidut Heart attack survivors have high stress (cortisol/adrenaline) hypersensitivity, low androgens Scientific Studies 2
haidut Stress-driven lipid peroxidation, inflammation re-awakens dormant cancer cells Scientific Studies 0
haidut Sexual activity and stress levels (HPA activity) may determine longevity Scientific Studies 12
L Ray Peat Interview Nov 2020 - Danny Roddy, Ray Peat, Georgi Dinkov - Bioenergetics, Thyroid, Stress, News Interviews 7
U How To Lower Stress Impact From Surgery? Cortisol, Serotonin, Histamine 0
Mito Vitamin D Supplementation During Winter: Effects On Stress Resilience D 10
haidut Low, Not High, Metabolism Creates Oxidative Stress Scientific Studies 2
U Is There A Way To Lift Weight Without Stress Response? Exercise 8
haidut Childhood Stress / Deprivation Leads To Early Puberty / Aging Scientific Studies 2
ScurveDream Change In Scenery -- Deterioration Mentally/physically -- Stress & Memories Miscellaneous Health Discussions 2
C Ulcers, H. Pylori, Malnutrition, & Plain Old Stress Digestion 45
Wabby1 Need Advice For Desperation And Stress During Pregnancy Mental Issues 18
Geronimo Stress Dysregulates Lung Function Stress 1
haidut Prenatal Stress Ups Serotonin, Which Causes Autism And Mental Disease In Offspring Scientific Studies 0
Energizer #33: NAD+/NADH, Stress, And Fatty Acids | How To Use T3, T4, And Aspirin | Histamine | Milk And Acne Danny Roddy 0
R How To Reduce Stress? Cortisol, Serotonin, Histamine 1
Lewis Acid Eugenol: Helps Reduce Loss Of Dopamine / Protects From Aluminum / Neuro-protective & Anti-stress Scientific Studies 12
koreus Tearful After Reducing Stress And Cortisol By Removing PUFA Cortisol, Serotonin, Histamine 11

Similar threads

Top