- Jan 11, 2019
So since i started upping my protein, my urine has a strong cleaning product smell. Should I be worried? Has anyone else experienced this?
Ill try adding taurine. I also want to mention, i pee a lot, like once an hour and it smells very strongly. Ill have to look more into it.Well, urine should smell a bit like ammonia, as that's the way we eliminate it. But if it's really strong and not transient, that could signal some issues.
You could lower protein intake, or try adding taurine. There's other methods to lower ammonia discussed on the forum (like biotin, B1, ceylon cinnamon, ornithine, etc)
If it's a really strong scent and consistent, it probably means you are wasting a lot of protein/amino acids.
Do u think that instead of infection causing a rise in acid it could be the increase of protein could cause a positive nitrogen balance increasing acid, causing the kidneys to increase urine to excrete it?To start with, I think that the more urine one excretes, the more it will smell from the quantity. But it's not just the quantity, but urinating a lot comes from the immune system either fighting an infection (low-level, internal meaning not in the gut but in the blood and in the ecf, or even intracellular, and not tested for as tests don't ID all pathogens) or itself dealing with itself in producing inflammation as it protects the body from toxins. Toxins could be heavy metals, LPS, immune complexes etc.
In my own experience, which I won't say applies to everyone, it's more likely due to infection that one urinates a lot. I would take antibiotics and then see if the urination rate would lower. I've been in a condition where I would urinate every 45 minutes, and came from a "no side-effect" proteolytic enzyme. I took it to lyse plaque from my blood vessels, but it released a lot of bacteria from the lysed plaque. As well as immune complexes.
The immune system would do its job of killing the bacteria, and a lot of water would be produced from this process which involves phagocytosis and with it producing ROS for the respiratory burst. I would check my CBC and look at my Wbc and neutrophils and monocytes to see if the values indicate a high degree of low-level Infection (low level means no fever involved).
I've also used chlorine dioxide recently, and found iit effective although it raised inflammation because I used too high a dose (90 ppm instead of 30ppm at 1ltr/day) and also because I have an immune complex condition in my kidneys which would be sensitive to the inflammatory effects of chlorine dioxide).
Usually though, to make things more conventional, I'd take antibiotics and see what happens. If the infection is a recurring issue, the you'd have to find a more natural form of antibiotic that doesn't confer resistance on the bacteria.
p.s. I think also that resolving the infection, or maybe the infection itself, causes acid to be produced, and if there's a lack of alkaline minerals in your system, the kidneys have to convert glutamate to make ammonium, which is needed to pair with an acidic anion to excrete acid through urine. So this may be why your urine smells a lot of ammonia. If you had more potassium stores, and potassium were used instead of ammonium, then your urine may not smell so much.
I'm not familiar with an increase in protein causing a positive nitrogen balance. Care to explain the mechanism further?Do u think that instead of infection causing a rise in acid it could be the increase of protein could cause a positive nitrogen balance increasing acid, causing the kidneys to increase urine to excrete it?
It's a very broad statement though. If it applies to all, then those consuming plenty of protein would have to pee a lot. But the problem with googling, is the information is not so usable. You can start experimenting based on that and reduce your protein intake and see what you arrive at. There may be a chance it reduces your urination, but you'd also have to consider the long term effect of doing that. I don't rely on Google for the top answers that show up, but still rely on it to dig through piles of mountain garbage to find gold though.Well i just googled it and it seems to be a thing, heres what its says "Large amounts of protein have a diuretic effect. Nitrogen is a bi-product of protein metabolism and is toxic. So, the body responds by pulling water from the tissues to flush it out. This is what leads to frequent urination and excessive thirst." @yerrag
Would lowered ammonia cause it to be excreted via urine? I eat lots of pineapple and this has tons of manganese in it. Heres a picture of the diet for context of what high protein means for meI think positive nitrogen balance just means you're ingesting more nitrogen than you're excreting.
The sulfur containing aminos, methionine and cysteine, do increase acid load in the body, but if you're ingesting a lot of potassium, like yerrag suggested, it shouldn't be a problem.
Maybe your urea cycle isn't handling the ammonia from the increased protein intake. I believe every whole protein( as in from food) releases some ammonia when it's being broken down. Ornithine, like tanka mentioned, is good at lowering ammonia. Another substance that does that is manganese, which, like ornithine, is present in the urea cycle.
Your manganese intake should be good then.Would lowered ammonia cause it to be excreted via urine? I eat lots of pineapple and this has tons of manganese in it. Heres a picture of the diet for context of what high protein means for me
I would not suspect an underlying medical condition or infection based on what you describe. Ammonia, is a waste product made by your body during the digestion of protein. Normally, ammonia is processed in the liver, where it is changed into another waste product called urea. Urea is passed through the body in urine.So since i started upping my protein, my urine has a strong cleaning product smell. Should I be worried? Has anyone else experienced this?
Pineapple is high serotonin. Bananas are high serotonin. Whey is a waste by product from the cheese industry and contains a lot of tryptophan which = high serotonin if it isn't converted properly to niacin. Muscle meat is high in tryptophan which = high serotonin (same as the whey). Romaine lettuce increases endotoxin which increases serotonin. There's a theme running through this you might consider.Would lowered ammonia cause it to be excreted via urine? I eat lots of pineapple and this has tons of manganese in it. Heres a picture of the diet for context of what high protein means for me
Just curious, what do you eat? I balance my whey with enough collagen and dont eat purely muscle meat (ground beef). I dont believe the seritonin in bananas and pineapple are really an issue. Pineapples have actually be found to be extremely pro-thyroid! You could be right, but none of this ammonia smell happened until i increased my protein intake, and until then i was still eating romaine, pineapple and banana.Pineapple is high serotonin. Bananas are high serotonin. Whey is a waste by product from the cheese industry and contains a lot of tryptophan which = high serotonin if it isn't converted properly to niacin. Muscle meat is high in tryptophan which = high serotonin (same as the whey). Romaine lettuce increases endotoxin which increases serotonin. There's a theme running through this you might consider.
A Ray Peat quote: ...ammonia molecule mimics the effects of serotonin, especially in fatigue, this could be involved in lithium’s antiserotonergic effects. Ammonia, like serotonin, impairs mitochondrial energy production (at a minimum, it uses energy in being converted to urea), so anti-ammonia, anti-serotonin agents make more energy available for adaptation. from here: Thyroid, insomnia, and the insanities: Commonalities in disease
search engine that's helpful: PeatSearch: a Ray Peat-specific search engine - Toxinless
Thiamine helps clear ammonia too.
|Grandma Has To Wake Up 3 Times To Pee At Night||Female Issues||14|
|I||Man Claims Drinking Pee Made His Hair Grow Back||Hair & Nails||17|
|A Good Urea Supplement? (BESIDES PEE!)||Supplements, Pharmaceutical Drugs||32|
|Smelly Pee||Ask For Help or Advice||3|
|Pain in lower right abdomen and pee-ing a lot. What is it?||Ask For Help or Advice||4|
|J||Pee and Vitamins||Vitamins||1|
|S||Sweat Smells Like Vinegar||Skin||1|
|M||Right Armpit Smells||Ask For Help or Advice||8|
|Gelatine. Smells Like Pig Urine||Gelatin||17|
|A||Urine Smells Like Vanilla Extract?||Ask For Help or Advice||3|
|Z||Skin Smells Like Urine||Skin||9|
|Fart Smells Like Eggs Since 1 Tbsp. Eggshells||Ask For Help or Advice||15|
|my urine smells sometimes, it didn't used to, is this good or bad?||Diet||3|
|R||Anyone have sensitivity to smells on Progest e||Supplements, Pharmaceutical Drugs||9|
|Coffe & Ammonia||Ask For Help or Advice||1|
|M||How To Keep Ammonia Low?||Ask For Help or Advice||4|
|How Is Low Serum Ammonia Related To Hypertension?||Heart, Heart Rate, Blood Pressure||23|
|A||Is There A Way To Completely Heal From Excess Ammonia Damage?||Ask For Help or Advice||15|
|FDA Approves Experior For Reduction Of Ammonia Gas Released From Beef Cattle Waste||Articles & Scientific Studies||4|
|E||Ammonia/Kidney Damage From Mercury Theory Of Autism||Health||9|
|Gut Microbes In Diabetics Produce Lactic Acid, Ammonia And Endotoxins||Digestion, Gut Flora||10|
|Cosmic Radiation Can Create Life-building Blocks From Ammonia & CO2||Scientific Studies||0|
|Schizophrenia Treatment Could Be As Simple As Reducing Ammonia||Scientific Studies||37|
|J||Gave Up Protein Drinks And Feeling A Lot Better (ammonia Smell Also Gone)||Ask For Help or Advice||13|
|Ammonia May Be The Direct Cause Of Ulcers In The Stomach||Scientific Studies||7|
|J||Ammonia Smelling Loose Stool||Digestion||7|
|Does Taking Lysine With Protein-rich Meals Increase Ammonia Levels?||Supplements, Pharmaceutical Drugs||3|
|Ammonia Toxicity To The Brain: Effects On Creatine Metabolism And Transport And Protective Roles||Articles & Scientific Studies||25|
|P||Fatigue, NH4 / Ammonia, Glutamine||Mental Issues||0|
|Aspirin Reduces Ammonia?||Aspirin||8|
|Biotin Reduces Ammonia Levels In Brain And Blood||Scientific Studies||25|
|Zinc Reduces Ammonia||Scientific Studies||4|
|Thiamine Reduces Both Lactate And Ammonia||Scientific Studies||100|
|C||Ammonia Scented Sweat||Hair & Nails||6|