goodandevil
Member
- Joined
- May 27, 2015
- Messages
- 978
Stop watching porn.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Click Here if you want to upgrade your account
If you were able to post but cannot do so now, send an email to admin at raypeatforum dot com and include your username and we will fix that right up for you.
I don't consider the benefits of meditation to be age dependent. I never suggested he meditate either but find out what bugs him about it. There's a whole lotta pent up negative energy inside and coming to grips with it is not without its benefits.cantstoppeating said:While meditating is great, the suggestion to do it depends on the context.
You wouldn't tell a teenager who's going through emotional turmoil to try "meditating". Or to read the Power of Now and start experiencing the "Now". Most self-help advice is for people 40 years and over who don't have the energy of youth (and all its turmoils) to distract them from the "now" or from their "inner sanctum".
The advice that actually works is the advice that helps them get out of their particular situation, and it's not politically correct e.g. if someone thinks they're ugly they should do all they can to at least look average, if someone is getting bullied they should do all they can to get stronger and fight back.
4peatssake said:I don't consider the benefits of meditation to be age dependent. I never suggested he meditate either but find out what bugs him about it. There's a whole lotta pent up negative energy inside and coming to grips with it is not without its benefits.cantstoppeating said:While meditating is great, the suggestion to do it depends on the context.
You wouldn't tell a teenager who's going through emotional turmoil to try "meditating". Or to read the Power of Now and start experiencing the "Now". Most self-help advice is for people 40 years and over who don't have the energy of youth (and all its turmoils) to distract them from the "now" or from their "inner sanctum".
The advice that actually works is the advice that helps them get out of their particular situation, and it's not politically correct e.g. if someone thinks they're ugly they should do all they can to at least look average, if someone is getting bullied they should do all they can to get stronger and fight back.
People who are older have lived through youth. I wouldn't summarily dismiss their advice because it doesn't personally fit for you.
People who are older have lived through youth. I wouldn't summarily dismiss their advice because it doesn't personally fit for you.
I did not suggest journaling, not by a long shot.cantstoppeating said:4peatssake said:I don't consider the benefits of meditation to be age dependent. I never suggested he meditate either but find out what bugs him about it. There's a whole lotta pent up negative energy inside and coming to grips with it is not without its benefits.cantstoppeating said:While meditating is great, the suggestion to do it depends on the context.
You wouldn't tell a teenager who's going through emotional turmoil to try "meditating". Or to read the Power of Now and start experiencing the "Now". Most self-help advice is for people 40 years and over who don't have the energy of youth (and all its turmoils) to distract them from the "now" or from their "inner sanctum".
The advice that actually works is the advice that helps them get out of their particular situation, and it's not politically correct e.g. if someone thinks they're ugly they should do all they can to at least look average, if someone is getting bullied they should do all they can to get stronger and fight back.
People who are older have lived through youth. I wouldn't summarily dismiss their advice because it doesn't personally fit for you.
My post wasn't directed at you but to the general idea that he should meditate. I don't consider the benefits of meditation to be age dependent either, it's very clear that it has real cognitive benefits independent of age, yet the context (i.e. the person and their situation) determines whether they will actually do it and thus affects its status as advice. While meditation is beneficial irrespective of age, it's not appropriate as advice irrespective of context.
For someone like "You", journaling or otherwise doing introspective work isn't going to help either -- he's already too stuck in his head, continuing to toil in his negative state. He needs to work on his physiology while simultaneously working on the two parts of himself I mentioned earlier in this thread.
People who are older have lived through youth. I wouldn't summarily dismiss their advice because it doesn't personally fit for you.
While experience is obviously a factor, the decrease in youth hormones and general ageing is severely underestimated. The most profound example is advice given to teenagers and young-adults to simply "not care what others think" while going through their most emotionally turmoil years. It's physiologically near-impossible to do otherwise. This advice unequivocally comes from parents and generally those in their 30s and over, who confuse cause and effect: they don't stop caring because they live through it, or gain experience, but because their youth-hormones have plummeted and they've become desensitised to the vagaries of youth.
4peatssake said:I did not suggest journaling, not by a long shot.
What I suggested was 3 pages a day of stream of consciousness writing in the morning - as a way of starting to get all that self hate out of himself. It's not a difficult exercise and I've seen it help a lot of people, not just people over 40.
I understand that you believe that you are right.
Others won't all share your point of view, just as you don't share mine.
Let's make room for everyone who wishes to help and you can decide what feels best for him.
4peatssake said:Edit to add: From what I understand, you are suggesting for him to take the rage, self hate and aggression and direct it toward physically improving himself and from that effort start to feel better about himself.
I prefer a solution that gives a person the ability to take those energies and transform them into positive energy without the use of aggression. Otherwise, you're still left with your anger.
It's difficult to converse with you because I experience so much judgement coming from you about what is being said and assumptions about older adults. And so everything I say has to be measured against those tendencies.cantstoppeating said:4peatssake said:I did not suggest journaling, not by a long shot.
What I suggested was 3 pages a day of stream of consciousness writing in the morning - as a way of starting to get all that self hate out of himself. It's not a difficult exercise and I've seen it help a lot of people, not just people over 40.
I understand that you believe that you are right.
Others won't all share your point of view, just as you don't share mine.
Let's make room for everyone who wishes to help and you can decide what feels best for him.
In psychiatry, depression is said to be internalised anger. It's a state of learned helplessness where a person feels their actions have no bearing on their state of being so they resign themselves to being passive. The solution is to invoke the anger outwards and channel it into assertiveness to get their needs met, whatever they may be. See the 'Anger map' attached below.
Writing down thoughts in a stream-of-consciousnouss style is great but do you really think it applies to someone in state of "rage, self hate and aggression"? It's more appropriate for someone with perhaps a menial stressful job who's biggest trouble is figuring out what he's going to eat for dinner.
4peatssake said:Edit to add: From what I understand, you are suggesting for him to take the rage, self hate and aggression and direct it toward physically improving himself and from that effort start to feel better about himself.
I prefer a solution that gives a person the ability to take those energies and transform them into positive energy without the use of aggression. Otherwise, you're still left with your anger.
I've seen nothing in your post to suggest your two solutions are mutually exclusive.
If you're saying that one should avoid the state of anger when trying to get out of depression, then that's an example of politically correct but practically useless advice. That's not a critique of you per se, but the mainstream zeitgeist that proliferates this feel-good baseless advice.
Anger Map:
Such_Saturation said:
4peatssake said:...
I don't consider there to be just one way to handle a problem. Sometimes just getting a severely depressed person to do anything that moves them forward is next to impossible and I have never once seen any sustainable forward movement without a shift in consciousness. If you only shift the anger from inward to outward, you're still left with all the anger and anger is a volatile fuel source. Not optimal.
Your method takes the fuel and releases it (temporarily) with physical activity. It's like letting some steam out of the pressure cooker. Certainly helpful if there is an enormous amount of pent up energy but not a permanent solution in and of itself. Furthermore, depending on one's physical stamina and well being which is compromised in a severely depressed person, rigorous physical activity can create further difficulties and injury which could further compound his negative views of himself.
...
4peatssake said:What I am suggesting is to take the fuel and harness it so one can effectively transform the fuel into beneficial energy to help oneself.
pboy said:on a real note though (although alcohol can in a sense train you and actually be a tool but its not ideal to need long term or all the time)
its basically a lack of confidence issue, which comes from lack of knowledge and experience or just not really having a personality, or being too afraid to let it show via being judged...which is either just because of shyness, or because your ashamed of your true self, in which case...do something about that. If you are humble you can always be confident, its usually only when people overstep themselves or have that tendency that they shut themselves down. If you are raw and innocent or a rookie, but have the right attitude about it, people are almost always inclusive and have fun bringing you in
narouz said:Sorry to interrupt,
but what does that icon mean
that is attached to his thread's subject heading
when you're looking at the "Board Index" page...?
The icon is a triangle with an exclamation point inside of it.
pboy said:on a real note though (although alcohol can in a sense train you and actually be a tool but its not ideal to need long term or all the time)
its basically a lack of confidence issue, which comes from lack of knowledge and experience or just not really having a personality, or being too afraid to let it show via being judged...which is either just because of shyness, or because your ashamed of your true self, in which case...do something about that. If you are humble you can always be confident, its usually only when people overstep themselves or have that tendency that they shut themselves down. If you are raw and innocent or a rookie, but have the right attitude about it, people are almost always inclusive and have fun bringing you in
narouz said:Sorry to interrupt,
but what does that icon mean
that is attached to his thread's subject heading
when you're looking at the "Board Index" page...?
The icon is a triangle with an exclamation point inside of it.
Charlie said:narouz said:Sorry to interrupt,
but what does that icon mean
that is attached to his thread's subject heading
when you're looking at the "Board Index" page...?
The icon is a triangle with an exclamation point inside of it.
It's a "Topic icon". When you are making a post you can choose between those 10 icons that are available.
Such_Saturation said:I can just imagine you flourishing within the loving embrace of a modern psychiatrist