List of safe cheeses made with animal rennet

Birdie

Member
Joined
Aug 10, 2012
Messages
5,783
Location
USA
No we get ours at another shop and no veg rennet. Maybe they make two versions? An upscale one and a lower version?

Oh My ? Eataly is amazing! Worth the drive. The cheeses are out of this world!! Here is the Vermont cheese:

View attachment 36424
That's beautiful.
 

Jennifer

Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2014
Messages
4,635
Location
USA
No we get ours at another shop and no veg rennet. Maybe they make two versions? An upscale one and a lower version?

Oh My ? Eataly is amazing! Worth the drive. The cheeses are out of this world!! Here is the Vermont cheese:

View attachment 36424

Oh, it is that one. Perfect! Thank you! I saw that exact cheese when I was looking for the cheddar and wondered if that was the Vermont one you were referring to. Again, thank you, Lisa. I so appreciate all your help. I'm super excited to check out Eataly. It sounds like a French girl's dream. :hearteyes:
 

Lollipop2

Member
Joined
Nov 18, 2019
Messages
5,267
Oh, it is that one. Perfect! Thank you! I saw that exact cheese when I was looking for the cheddar and wondered if that was the Vermont one you were referring to. Again, thank you, Lisa. I so appreciate all your help. I'm super excited to check out Eataly. It sounds like a French girl's dream. :hearteyes:
You are most welcome Jennifer ❤️ Now I am going to find out about that 1833 cheese. Going to go ask the cheese shop I get it from - on the hunt for truth…
 

Lollipop2

Member
Joined
Nov 18, 2019
Messages
5,267
@Lollipop2, I think you're right about there being two versions. I came across this:

Very interesting! That link is exactly what our label shows. Animal rennet.

I also remembered that there is a 40 month or 4 years aged version. So it looks like three age versions: 18 mths, 24 myths, 40mths. We get the 24 mth and longer aged one. Anyway my eyes are open!!

We found another good cheddar from Ireland “Neal’s Yard”. No veg rennet but animal rennet. You might check it out for your father.
 

Jennifer

Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2014
Messages
4,635
Location
USA
Very interesting! That link is exactly what our label shows. Animal rennet.

I also remembered that there is a 40 month or 4 years aged version. So it looks like three age versions: 18 mths, 24 myths, 40mths. We get the 24 mth and longer aged one. Anyway my eyes are open!!

We found another good cheddar from Ireland “Neal’s Yard”. No veg rennet but animal rennet. You might check it out for your father.

Oh, that’s good to know. I’ll make sure then that I’m getting the 18 version for my dad. And thank you for mentioning Neal’s Yard. The cheese list is growing. YAY!
 

Jennifer

Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2014
Messages
4,635
Location
USA
I completely forgot I had the farms below saved in my notes. I went through all of the cheese that are free of vegetable rennet and just in case, have numbered them so that it’s easier for you to remember where you left off:

Amos Miller Organic Farm

1. Buffalo A2/A2 Cottage Cheese – Glass – PINT – Amos Miller Organic Farm

2. Buffalo A2/A2 Soft Cheese – 8 oz – Amos Miller Organic Farm

3. Buffalo A2/A2 Camenbuff – 6 oz Wheel – Amos Miller Organic Farm

4. Mild Cheddar – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

5. Mild Cheddar – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

6. Sharp Cheddar – 1 lb Avg – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

7. Sharp Cheddar – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

8. Smoked Cheddar – Salted – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

9. Aged Mozzarella – Salted – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

10. Cottage Cheese – Glass – PINT – Amos Miller Organic Farm

11. Cottage Cheese – GLASS – QUART – Amos Miller Organic Farm

12. Cottage Cheese – plastic – PINT – Amos Miller Organic Farm

13. Cheese Spread – Amos Miller Organic Farm

14. Cream Cheese – Amos Miller Organic Farm

15. Raw Frasier Cheese – A2/A2 – NO SALT – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

16. Cottage Cheese – A2/A2 – Glass – PINT – Amos Miller Organic Farm

17. Cottage Cheese – A2/A2 – PINT – Amos Miller Organic Farm

18. A2/A2 Cream Cheese – Amos Miller Organic Farm

19. Mild Cheddar – A2/A2 – Salted – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

20. Mild Cheddar – A2/A2 – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

21. Mild Cheddar – A2/A2 – No Salt – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

22. Mild Cheddar – A2/A2 – No Salt – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

23. Sharp Cheddar – A2/A2 – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

24. Sharp Cheddar – A2/A2 – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

25. Sharp Cheddar – A2/A2 – No Salt – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

26. Swiss Cheese – A2/A2 – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

27. Swiss Cheese – A2/A2 – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

28. Swiss Cheese – A2/A2 – No Salt – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

29. Garlic Cheddar – A2/A2 – Salted – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

30. Garlic Cheddar – A2/A2 – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

31. Pepper Jack – A2/A2 – Salted – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

32. Pepper Jack – A2/A2 – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

33. Gouda Cheese – A2/A2 – Salted – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

34. Gouda Cheese – A2/A2 – No Salt – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

35. Gouda Cheese – A2/A2 – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

36. Gouda Cheese – A2/A2 – No Salt – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

37. Havarti Cheese – A2/A2 – Salted – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

38. Havarti Cheese – A2/A2 – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

39. Colby Cheese – A2/A2 – Salted – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

40. Colby Cheese – A2/A2 – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

41. Herbal Jack – A2/A2 – Salted – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

42. Herbal Jack – A2/A2 – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

43. Monterey Jack – A2/A2 – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

44. Monterey Jack – A2/A2 – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

45. Monterey Jack – A2/A2 – No Salt – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

46. Farmers Cheese – A2/A2 – Salted – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

47. Farmers Cheese – A2/A2 – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

48. Sheep – Feta Cheese – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

49. Sheep Cottage Cheese – A2/A2 – PINT – Amos Miller Organic Farm

Buffalo Valley Pastures

1. Buffalo Wing Colby (20 oz.)

2. Buffalo Wing Colby (8 oz.)

3. Colby Cheese (20 oz.)

4. Colby Cheese (5 lb.)

5. Colby Cheese (8 oz.)

6. Fresh Cow Paneer (1 lb.)

7. Garlic Cheddar (20 oz.)

8. Garlic Cheddar (5 lb.)

9. Garlic Cheddar (8 oz.)

10. Herbal Jack Cheese (20 oz.)

11. Herbal Jack Cheese (5 lb.)

12. Herbal Jack Cheese (8 oz.)

13. Hot Jack Cheese (20 oz.)

14. Hot Jack Cheese (5 lb.)

15. Hot Jack Cheese (8 oz.)

16. Jack Cheese (20 oz.)

17. Jack Cheese (5 lb.)

18. Jack Cheese (8 oz.)

19. Mild Cheddar Cheese (8 oz.)

20. Mild Cheddar Cheese (20 oz.)

21. Mild Cheddar Cheese (5 lb.)

22. Smoked Cheddar Cheese (20 oz.)

23. Smoked Cheddar Cheese (8 oz.)

24. Smoked Colby Cheese (20 oz.)

25. Smoked Colby Cheese (8 oz.)

26. Smoked Water Buffalo Cheddar (8 oz.)

27. Unsalted Cheddar Cheese (20 oz.)

28. Unsalted Cheddar Cheese (5 lb.)

29. Water Buffalo Cheddar (8 oz.)

30. Water Buffalo Gouda (1 lb.)

31. Water Buffalo Gouda (8 oz.)

32. Yogurt Cheese (20 oz.)

33. Yogurt Cheese (8 oz.)

34. Yogurt Cheese (5 lb.)

Miller’s Bio Farm

1. Raw A2 Mild Cheddar Cheese

2. Raw A2 Mild Cheddar Cheese

3. A2 Raw Mild Cheddar Cheese

4. Raw A2 Sharp Cheddar Cheese

5. Raw A2 Sharp Cheddar Cheese

6. A2 Raw Colby Cheese

7. Raw A2 Colby Cheese

8. Raw A2 Gouda Cheese

9. Raw A2 Gouda Cheese

10. A2 Raw Swiss Cheese

11. Raw A2 Swiss Cheese

12. Raw A2 Tomato Basil Cheddar Cheese

13. Raw A2 Smoked Cheddar Cheese

Shredded cheese without anti-caking agents and mold inhibitors/natamycin:

1. Raw A2 Shredded Mild Cheddar Cheese

2. https://millersbiofarm.com/store/pr...y-cheese-may-taste-slightly-sour-6-months-old
 

Lollipop2

Member
Joined
Nov 18, 2019
Messages
5,267
I completely forgot I had the farms below saved in my notes. I went through all of the cheese that are free of vegetable rennet and just in case, have numbered them so that it’s easier for you to remember where you left off:

Amos Miller Organic Farm

1. Buffalo A2/A2 Cottage Cheese – Glass – PINT – Amos Miller Organic Farm

2. Buffalo A2/A2 Soft Cheese – 8 oz – Amos Miller Organic Farm

3. Buffalo A2/A2 Camenbuff – 6 oz Wheel – Amos Miller Organic Farm

4. Mild Cheddar – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

5. Mild Cheddar – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

6. Sharp Cheddar – 1 lb Avg – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

7. Sharp Cheddar – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

8. Smoked Cheddar – Salted – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

9. Aged Mozzarella – Salted – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

10. Cottage Cheese – Glass – PINT – Amos Miller Organic Farm

11. Cottage Cheese – GLASS – QUART – Amos Miller Organic Farm

12. Cottage Cheese – plastic – PINT – Amos Miller Organic Farm

13. Cheese Spread – Amos Miller Organic Farm

14. Cream Cheese – Amos Miller Organic Farm

15. Raw Frasier Cheese – A2/A2 – NO SALT – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

16. Cottage Cheese – A2/A2 – Glass – PINT – Amos Miller Organic Farm

17. Cottage Cheese – A2/A2 – PINT – Amos Miller Organic Farm

18. A2/A2 Cream Cheese – Amos Miller Organic Farm

19. Mild Cheddar – A2/A2 – Salted – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

20. Mild Cheddar – A2/A2 – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

21. Mild Cheddar – A2/A2 – No Salt – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

22. Mild Cheddar – A2/A2 – No Salt – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

23. Sharp Cheddar – A2/A2 – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

24. Sharp Cheddar – A2/A2 – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

25. Sharp Cheddar – A2/A2 – No Salt – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

26. Swiss Cheese – A2/A2 – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

27. Swiss Cheese – A2/A2 – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

28. Swiss Cheese – A2/A2 – No Salt – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

29. Garlic Cheddar – A2/A2 – Salted – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

30. Garlic Cheddar – A2/A2 – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

31. Pepper Jack – A2/A2 – Salted – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

32. Pepper Jack – A2/A2 – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

33. Gouda Cheese – A2/A2 – Salted – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

34. Gouda Cheese – A2/A2 – No Salt – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

35. Gouda Cheese – A2/A2 – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

36. Gouda Cheese – A2/A2 – No Salt – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

37. Havarti Cheese – A2/A2 – Salted – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

38. Havarti Cheese – A2/A2 – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

39. Colby Cheese – A2/A2 – Salted – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

40. Colby Cheese – A2/A2 – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

41. Herbal Jack – A2/A2 – Salted – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

42. Herbal Jack – A2/A2 – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

43. Monterey Jack – A2/A2 – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

44. Monterey Jack – A2/A2 – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

45. Monterey Jack – A2/A2 – No Salt – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

46. Farmers Cheese – A2/A2 – Salted – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

47. Farmers Cheese – A2/A2 – Salted – 5-6 lb Block – Amos Miller Organic Farm

48. Sheep – Feta Cheese – per lb – Amos Miller Organic Farm

49. Sheep Cottage Cheese – A2/A2 – PINT – Amos Miller Organic Farm

Buffalo Valley Pastures

1. Buffalo Wing Colby (20 oz.)

2. Buffalo Wing Colby (8 oz.)

3. Colby Cheese (20 oz.)

4. Colby Cheese (5 lb.)

5. Colby Cheese (8 oz.)

6. Fresh Cow Paneer (1 lb.)

7. Garlic Cheddar (20 oz.)

8. Garlic Cheddar (5 lb.)

9. Garlic Cheddar (8 oz.)

10. Herbal Jack Cheese (20 oz.)

11. Herbal Jack Cheese (5 lb.)

12. Herbal Jack Cheese (8 oz.)

13. Hot Jack Cheese (20 oz.)

14. Hot Jack Cheese (5 lb.)

15. Hot Jack Cheese (8 oz.)

16. Jack Cheese (20 oz.)

17. Jack Cheese (5 lb.)

18. Jack Cheese (8 oz.)

19. Mild Cheddar Cheese (8 oz.)

20. Mild Cheddar Cheese (20 oz.)

21. Mild Cheddar Cheese (5 lb.)

22. Smoked Cheddar Cheese (20 oz.)

23. Smoked Cheddar Cheese (8 oz.)

24. Smoked Colby Cheese (20 oz.)

25. Smoked Colby Cheese (8 oz.)

26. Smoked Water Buffalo Cheddar (8 oz.)

27. Unsalted Cheddar Cheese (20 oz.)

28. Unsalted Cheddar Cheese (5 lb.)

29. Water Buffalo Cheddar (8 oz.)

30. Water Buffalo Gouda (1 lb.)

31. Water Buffalo Gouda (8 oz.)

32. Yogurt Cheese (20 oz.)

33. Yogurt Cheese (8 oz.)

34. Yogurt Cheese (5 lb.)

Miller’s Bio Farm

1. Raw A2 Mild Cheddar Cheese

2. Raw A2 Mild Cheddar Cheese

3. A2 Raw Mild Cheddar Cheese

4. Raw A2 Sharp Cheddar Cheese

5. Raw A2 Sharp Cheddar Cheese

6. A2 Raw Colby Cheese

7. Raw A2 Colby Cheese

8. Raw A2 Gouda Cheese

9. Raw A2 Gouda Cheese

10. A2 Raw Swiss Cheese

11. Raw A2 Swiss Cheese

12. Raw A2 Tomato Basil Cheddar Cheese

13. Raw A2 Smoked Cheddar Cheese

Shredded cheese without anti-caking agents and mold inhibitors/natamycin:

1. Raw A2 Shredded Mild Cheddar Cheese

2. Raw A2 Shredded Mild Cheddar Cheese
@Jennifer THIS ROCKS IT!! I have noticed you do a superb job of gathering lists of healthy resources for many different things. If anyone is reading this go back through her posts for some fabulous lists. She is amazing ?
 

Jennifer

Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2014
Messages
4,635
Location
USA
@Jennifer THIS ROCKS IT!! I have noticed you do a superb job of gathering lists of healthy resources for many different things. If anyone is reading this go back through her posts for some fabulous lists. She is amazing ?

Thank you for your kind words, Lisa. You're amazing, too. ❤️
 

Birdie

Member
Joined
Aug 10, 2012
Messages
5,783
Location
USA
❤️
 

76er

Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2021
Messages
198
The following are all made w/ animal rennet and can be found at Hannafords (grocery store in the Northeast US):

- Olympiana Grass-fed Feta
- Agriform Parmigiano Reggiano
- Beemster Classic Gouda - but it seems that all their cheeses are made with animal rennet.
 

Lollipop2

Member
Joined
Nov 18, 2019
Messages
5,267
The following are all made w/ animal rennet and can be found at Hannafords (grocery store in the Northeast US):

- Olympiana Grass-fed Feta
- Agriform Parmigiano Reggiano
- Beemster Classic Gouda - but it seems that all their cheeses are made with animal rennet.
Hey thanks! Nice :):
 

Birdie

Member
Joined
Aug 10, 2012
Messages
5,783
Location
USA
I accidentally bought Boar's Head gouda when I was in hurry. The stuff with the synthetic rennet tastes awful. Also, recently I bought some gouda that was placed in the spot (Fresh Market's bin) where they always had the real rennet kind. This one was horrible. Using it in an omelette, it was actually nauseating. It was not from Holland but had a thin red wax on it which fooled me. Good news though is that the Red Wax Gouda was in stock last time I was there.

Publix, where I bought the Boar's Head accidentally, has Gayo Azul from Holland with rennet. It tastes good, so hopefully the rennet is real in it.

Things are getting harder as supplies dry up...
 

Similar threads

Back
Top Bottom