Frozen oyster/shrimp sources?

Dan Wich

Jan 22, 2013
Anyone have any recommendations for frozen-shipped seafood? My local stores aren't reliable for non-farmed, non-canned oysters/shrimp.

So far Cajun Grocer looks decent for gulf shrimp. You can get them for around $12/lb shipped (peeled and deveined, individually-quick-frozen) if you get the smaller shrimp and larger quantities.

Any other suggestions?


Sep 22, 2013
No experience with any mailorder shrimp sources, but just FYI I have been able to reliably find frozen wild caught shrimp from the Gulf of Mexico at the Costco here. They are about $40 for a four pound bag if I remember correctly. Don't have a membership myself but my mom does so sometimes I'll make a trip there with her and stock up. Might be worth a look if you know someone with a membership, but even if you don't here is a potential way around it: ... rship.html


Jun 14, 2013
Tucson, AZ
From what I've been lead to understand, when it comes to oysters "farmed" ones are actually preferred over wild ones for the most part. Since oysters are filter feeders the farmers have no need to feed them anything, good or bad. They probably really couldn't feed them even if they tried since osmosis would wash away anything they put into the water.(ocean) Farming also doesn't damage the reefs of natural oyster beds here/there/wherever which is very eco-friendly. They basically have to dredge wild ones up out of the natural sediment.

There were a few other key points but those are the main two that stood out in my mind. I just googled "farmed vs. wild oysters" or something along those lines. :2cents
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
H Frozen raw oysters Seafood 1
Vileplume Digesting Frozen V Fresh Milk Digestion 7
J Why Does Fresh Liver Taste So Good But Frozen Liver So Meh? Organ Meat 3
I Frozen Feet Ask For Help or Advice 73
L Is Reconstitued Frozen OJ Concentrate Supposed To Separate? Fruit Juice 4
SOMO PSA: Costco Frozen Berries Contaminated With Hepatitis A Breaking News 3
T Frozen Orchic Extract From Bovine, Opinions? Ask For Help or Advice 9
T Frozen Orchic Extract From Bovine, Opinions? Supplements, Pharmaceutical Drugs 2
Centsmom Frozen Fruit Ray Peat Topics 9
Philomath Fresh Bone Broth Delivered Frozen To Your Door Broth, Stocks 10
I Sweaty and frozen feet iLoveSugar 1
B Eating fish, the frozen fillets? Seafood 18
J Best Oyster Brand Seafood 7
M Oyster Problem Ask For Help or Advice 18
A Oyster Shell Calcium (calcium Carbonate) Prevents Cancer Scientific Studies 4
L Are You Worried About Antacid Effects Of Calcium Carbonate (tablets, Eggshell, Oyster Shell)? Calcium 16
debored13 Oyster Overdose, Help Please Seafood 24
sprinter What Is The Best Calcium Supp After Eggshell And Oyster Supplements, Pharmaceutical Drugs 17
sprinter Liver And Oyster 1x Week On Same Day Ask For Help or Advice 3
B Oyster Soup Recipe Using Boiled In Water Canned Recipes 13
R Oyster Shell Brand Calcium 4
E Oyster shell or calcium supp Calcium 5
4peatssake Classic Creamy Oyster Stew Recipes 3
gilson d dantas Shrimp And Selenium Blood Work, Labs 42
J A Few Other High Vitamin E Foods- Carp, Shark, Flounder, Shrimp E 0
L Eating Shrimp Every Day Seafood 16
biggirlkisss Is Shrimp Actaully Not That High In Copper Ask For Help or Advice 7
B How To Cook Prawn/shrimp? Recipes 31
J Shrimp And OJ Make Me Horny Baby! Male Issues 20
B What To Eat With Shrimp Recipes 27
taesch Shrimp, Oysters And Blue Crab High BMAA Articles & Scientific Studies 1
natedawggh Shrimp And Weight Loss? Seafood 16
tomisonbottom Shrimp bisque Recipes 3
loess Do you devein your shrimp? Seafood 2
S Shrimp's Peat Log- Thyroid, Anxiety And Acne Issues, Oh My! Logs 354
charlie Shrimp Make Me Hot! Seafood 14

Similar threads