For Those Who "crave" Starch, Are You Sure It's Not The Fiber Or The Salt?

Prosper

Member
Joined
Mar 1, 2017
Messages
516
I have consistently satisfied my "carb cravings" by either eating unjuiced & dried fruits with all the fiber and/or taken an additional teaspoon of salt with my meals. During the period I've been paying attention to this, not even once has there been a vague hunger for potato or rice that wasn't effectively satisfied by something more peat-like instead.
 

Tenacity

Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2016
Messages
844
The only 'starch' I have ever craved since 'Peating' is pizza, and only when it was right in front of me.
 
OP
Prosper

Prosper

Member
Joined
Mar 1, 2017
Messages
516
The only 'starch' I have ever craved since 'Peating' is pizza, and only when it was right in front of me.
And even that craving is probably mostly about the saturated fat + sugary coke that having a pizza "right in front of you" usually translates to :D
 

johnwester130

Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2015
Messages
3,563
yes, it is a craving for salt.

but how else can you get salt in the diet ? dried fruit wouldn't work
 

Tenacity

Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2016
Messages
844
And even that craving is probably mostly about the saturated fat + sugary coke that having a pizza "right in front of you" usually translates to :D

That's exactly right, the salt too.

yes, it is a craving for salt.

but how else can you get salt in the diet ? dried fruit wouldn't work

Natural starches don't really come with salt anyway, so I'm assuming the craving is associative. If you started adding salt to other things you'd likely crave those things instead of starches. Sweet and salty popcorn is proof that sugar and salt can combine quite nicely, so although relatively unheard of it's probably possible to create both sugary and salty dishes. Salted caramel ice cream springs to mind.

I'm not anti-starch either. I think there's good reasons human beings have eaten starch, particularly starchy tubers, for so long.
 

Arnold Grape

Member
Joined
Jan 24, 2017
Messages
601
Location
Upstate
In one year I have learned to differentiate between cravings and I can pretty much tell you that one can want (and feel satiated after) eating rice or potatoes, which is btw a different type of satiation.
 

johnwester130

Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2015
Messages
3,563
That's exactly right, the salt too.



Natural starches don't really come with salt anyway, so I'm assuming the craving is associative. If you started adding salt to other things you'd likely crave those things instead of starches. Sweet and salty popcorn is proof that sugar and salt can combine quite nicely, so although relatively unheard of it's probably possible to create both sugary and salty dishes. Salted caramel ice cream springs to mind.

I'm not anti-starch either. I think there's good reasons human beings have eaten starch, particularly starchy tubers, for so long.


so salted fruit ? salted eggs with fruit ?

the peat article is confusing. was he referring to kellogs corn flakes and white bread or potatoes and masa harina ? or both ?

the peat diet has a type of nihilism about it.
many cultures eat according to weather, the season and how you actually feel.
 
Joined
Nov 26, 2013
Messages
7,370
I agree. But also you crave the rapid blood sugar increase. You may notice during "cravings" that you are feeling cold (your temp might be fine though).
 
Joined
Nov 26, 2013
Messages
7,370
Yes, I have noticed this. What is the best thing to do?
I don't really know, I don't get it too often and I always have starch or some junk food at hand :ss I've had partial success with simple sugars, salt, coconut oil. It sucks because apart from the cravings, my body works better than usual then, but it's hard to bear. It almost feels like you are breaking a threshold and need some kind of opiaceous feeling to bring you back down to comfort, as if you aren't ready for that state yet.
 
Joined
Feb 4, 2015
Messages
1,972
We crave starch because the human being is the only animal to consume cooked starch in its natural diet and the human being the highest producing savilary and pancreatic amylase producing animal, the enzyme that breaks down starch. We were cooking starch before we were human in this form.

Our craving for carbohydrate varies from sweet to soothing and savory. It's not about salt. It's about satiation from carbohydrate. Many people will tell you that they don't feel well on fruit and lactose as their main carb sources. Starch solves their problem. Not salt. You don't know about it because they don't post publicly here too much.

Fruit is a light fuel for many. Starch is more energy producing for these types.
 

ilikecats

Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2016
Messages
633
Its not just the salt but the lack of water. I drink probably at least a gallon and a half of liquids but I ingest around 2 tablespoons of salt throughout the day. Don't forget that the hypothyroid state is a state of constant hyponatremia
 

theLaw

Member
Joined
Mar 7, 2017
Messages
1,403
I think the "starch' craving is simply a need for dense calories or salt.

Starch is a perfect salt-delivery tool, and it's hard to find others ways to get nearly 1T of salt into the diet without some discomfort.

Cheesecake or Milk-Powder cookies would probably be a tasty food to deal with "starch" cravings.
 

nbznj

Member
Joined
Oct 4, 2017
Messages
287
salt as in added salt isn't needed in the human diet. The Na:K ratio should remain about 1:4. If you sweat a bunch, consume more of both. Anywhere between 1 to 2 grams a day is very fine (from sedentary to very active).

I never really crave starches although I do eat a couple of bananas a day. If I do crave starch it's whole/sourdough bread and I'm not surprised, it's chock full of nutrients and goes very well with a bit of garlic butter.
 

Wagner83

Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2016
Messages
3,295
salt as in added salt isn't needed in the human diet. The Na:K ratio should remain about 1:4.
How did you end up with that ratio? @Travis suggested something like 1:10 and studies which checked the ratios in various tissues of bisons and sheepsh found different numbers and very different ratio depending on the tissues. In his article on salt Ray makes a good case for salt intake. Then some people who tried a low-salt diet found their cravings for salt adjusted over time, so that suggests eating fit based on cravings is not necessarily right.
 
OP
Prosper

Prosper

Member
Joined
Mar 1, 2017
Messages
516
salt as in added salt isn't needed in the human diet. The Na:K ratio should remain about 1:4. If you sweat a bunch, consume more of both. Anywhere between 1 to 2 grams a day is very fine (from sedentary to very active).

I have wondered whether there is a difference between salt requirements of those who swim in sea vs those who don't. Most of human evolution has probably happened near oceans where getting enough salt was convenient.
 

nbznj

Member
Joined
Oct 4, 2017
Messages
287
actually 1:10 might be even better if we reduce salt even further and keep Potassium between 5 and 10 grams a day. But 1:4 is found in human and mammalian milk so I go by this ratio (seems below) plus it's intuitive; when I actually decide to track my weekly intake I end up around 1:4 give or take.

The 2001 Osaka study quoted here is a great read that shows how the metabolism goes crazy on an excessive salt intake.

https://health.gov/dietaryguidelines/dga2015/comments/uploads/CID3982_Sandor2013-Heart-org2014.pdf

page 3; lots of very good studies quoted here. It's unfortunate that the author's english is a bit off which makes him sound unscientific at times.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top Bottom