Mar 18, 2013
USA / Europe
There is a very famous theory in reproductive biology still considered the dominant one in its field. Namely, males have to accept a trade-off between androgen levels and immunity. It is known as the immunocompetence handicap hypothesis (ICHH). Higher androgen levels, the theory goes, allow the male to (physically) outcompete other males around him for access to females and food. However, this comes at the cost of reduced immunity because, the theory goes, androgens destroy the thymus and thus lower resistance to infectious diseases.

Handicap principle - Wikipedia

Fortunately, and as has become quite common lately with dominant "scientific" theories, this one also seems to be based on nothing but idiotism and political motivations. Multiple studies have challenged the theory however it still remains dominant in reproductive biology to this day. This situation is mostly due to the solid evidence that demonstrates testosterone to indeed have a powerful atrophic effect on the thymus, and castration to regenerate thymus even in old animals.

No evidence for the immunocompetence handicap hypothesis in male humans

There is of course another, quite simple explanation. Testosterone easily aromatizes into estrogen and this process accelerates with age (and increase fat mass). Castration lowers not only testosterone but also estradiol, to undetectable levels. So, the simple and intuitive explanation would be that it is the conversion of (aromatizable) androgens into estrogens that has atrophic effects on the thymus, and not the androgens themselves. It is an explanation that fits the available clinical observations perfectly. Namely, with advancing age the estrogen/androgen and cortisol/DHEA ratios keep rising and reach a peak at time of death. The same increase in ratios is seen in virtually all chronic conditions such as CVD, diabetes, cancer, neurodegenerative disease, life-threatening infections, sepsis, etc. As such, one could come to the conclusion that lowering those ratios should regenerate the thymus, even in older animals. Some approaches for achieving that goal would be inhibiting the synthesis of estrogen (with aromatase inhibitor (AI) drugs), and/or blocking excessive glucocorticoid activity (by administering progesterone+DHEA). Indeed, if one cares to do a little searching, there are several studies that demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach in both male and female organisms.

Aromatase inhibitors regenerate the thymus in aging male rats. - PubMed - NCBI
Effects of an aromatase inhibitor on testosterone-induced inhibition of thymus growth in immature female rats. - PubMed - NCBI
Human Age Reversed By 2.5 Years By Combo Of Metformin, DHEA And GH

"...The combination of testosterone and ATD significantly increased body weight gain, and oestradiol significantly decreased it. Thymus growth was inhibited by both doses of testosterone and by oestradiol, but not by DHT. ATD alone did not inhibit thymus growth, nor did the lower dose of ATD inhibit the action of testosterone. The higher dose of ATD did, however, significantly reduce the inhibitory action of testosterone on the thymus. The inhibitory action of testosterone on the growing thymus may be due, at least in part, to its conversion to oestradiol."

As the quote from the second study above suggests, if it is indeed estrogen (and cortisol) and not androgens responsible for atrophy of the thymus then we'd expect non-aromatizable androgens such as DHT to not cause atrophy. Interestingly enough, there are almost no studies with DHT on any aspect of health except, of course, its widely publicized role as the "evil" androgen that causes prostate cancer and male baldness. However, if one looks into older studies from times when DHT was not as vilified as it is today, the evidence is there in plain view. In light of all the recent studies pointing to the role of suppressed immune system in cancer, one can only wonder if the widespread "treatments" with estrogen and cortisol (the 2 most destructive steroids for immunity) for patients of both sexes for all sorts of conditions are perhaps the main reason for the massive increase in cancer rates (and deaths)...

Effects of various steroids on the thymus, spleen, ventral prostate and seminal vesicles in old orchidectomized rats. - PubMed - NCBI

"...The differences between the effects of the steroids were most apparent when considering the histological appearance of the thymus. In testosterone- and oestradiol-treated animals there was a severe depletion of thymic lymphocytes in the cortical region, which was narrow, and the corticomedullaryjunction was ill-defined (results not shown). There were areas of fatty tissue which we have always seen in age-related cases of thymic involution. In contrast, the thymus from DHT-treated animals was normal and indistinguishable from that of orchidectomized sham-treated animals or from normal young rats (results not shown);"

"...The pattern of total white cell counts obtained is shown in Fig. la. In blood from testosterone-treated rats the total white cell count was significantly (P<0-01) lower than that in blood from sham-treated rats. The total white cell count was also significantly ( <0 5) reduced in oestradiol- and corticosteronetreated rats, but not in rats treated with progesterone or DHT. Table 1 shows the results of the differential white cell count. From this it may be deduced that the reduction was due possibly to changes in the lymphocyte count. In all steroid-treated groups the neutrophil count was markedly increased."

"...Dihydrotestosterone is generally considered to be the potent active metabolite of testosterone, but it appeared to have no involutionary effect on the regenerating thymus, despite the reduction in weight compared with that of untreated animals. Furthermore, DHT did not reduce the total white cell count significantly. A possible explanation for the different effects of testosterone and DHT may be provided by Pearce, Khalid & Funder (1981) who injected DHT chronically into intact and orchidectomized male mice. Dihydrotestosterone had no effect on the thymus of intact mice...Testosterone markedly involutes the thymus in intact males (Selye & Albert, 1942a)."


Jan 25, 2014
This is a pretty incredible post, almost hard to believe it's been up a year, with no comments. I know I've seen this theory before, but don't think I have seen this study referenced. Nice.

Good to know for men experimenting with P4 and DHEA, that adding a non-aromatizable androgen to the mix won't take away from regeneration effects on the thymus, and in fact will likely compliment them.
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
haidut Gynecomastia Associated With Low Androgens, High Cortisol / Estrogen / Prolactin / LH / FSH Scientific Studies 7
haidut Fasting ups estrogen & cortisol, decimates vitamin D, may cause diabetes Scientific Studies 11
A NLR As Marker Of Estrogen And Cortisol Levels Scientific Studies 9
Peatogenic If Endotoxin Isn't Under Control, Can't Anti Estrogen/cortisol Efforts Actually Increase Them? Supplements, Pharmaceutical Drugs 35
T Thyroid, Cortisol, Prolactin, Estrogen, Testosterone Are Normal - So Why Are Temps And Pulse So Low? Blood Work, Labs 29
F Either Adrenal Fatigue Or High Cortisol And Estrogen Dominance Question Cortisol, Serotonin, Histamine 52
Zpol Anti-cortisol/estrogen/serotonin That DOESN'T Worsen Constipation? Supplements 23
haidut PUFA Is Directly Catabolic (without Cortisol/estrogen), SFA Is Anabolic Scientific Studies 5
haidut Cortisol/Estrogen Impair Fertility; Progesterone/Pregnenolone Improve It Scientific Studies 7
D Cortisol Lowers Estrogen - Cortisol Used To Treat Cancer, Autoimmunity, And More Ask For Help or Advice 24
P Effects Of Estrogen Versus Estrogen And Progesterone On Cortisol And Interleukin-6 Articles & Scientific Studies 0
haidut Depression May Be Caused By Estrogen In Females And Cortisol In Males Scientific Studies 35
D DHT Lowers Cortisol, Estrogen And Is Neuroprotective Thyroid and Hormones 70
haidut Stress Elevates Estrogen, Not Just Cortisol Scientific Studies 2
haidut Plasticisers (bpa, Dehp) Boost Pufa, Estrogen, Cortisol & Block Glucose Oxidation Scientific Studies 34
haidut Cyproheptadine Blocks Cortisol Excess Due To Hypoglycemia / Estrogen Scientific Studies 30
R Fixing Estrogen, Cortisol And Water Retention Health 7
sunmountain High Estrogen, Cortisol, Adrenaline, Serotonin, Prolactin Symptoms Symptoms, Causes 63
juanitacarlos Coffee [Cortisol, Estrogen] Coffee 33
G My high estrogen won't drop. Help Ask For Help or Advice 27
NodeCerebri Can’t seem to come out of estrogen dominance. Tried everything already Ask For Help or Advice 60
D Is Beard Growth Androgen, Estrogen, or Nitric Oxide related? Or all the above? Male Issues 30
Nfinkelstein What supplement best for estrogen clearance Ask For Help or Advice 17
P Why Does Lowering Estrogen Slow My Hair Loss? (Interesting experience) Hair & Nails 4
Lokzo Testosterone As Well As Estrogen Increases Serotonin2A Receptor MRNA Scientific Studies 0
J Fat And "LOW" Estrogen/low Libido After Andro/pansterone/VitE Ask For Help or Advice 28
Hgreen56 If Joint Pain Is Caused By Low Estrogen, How To Solve This Problem Eyes, Ears, Nose and Headaches/Migraines 6
haidut Lowering Estrogen Prevents Memory Decline In Menopausal Females Scientific Studies 0
haidut Estrogen Can Both Cause And Exacerbate Lupus Scientific Studies 0
haidut Estrogen May Be The Cause Of "estrogen-negative" Breast Cancer Scientific Studies 0
haidut Androgens Boost, Estrogen Inhibits, Anti-aging Gene Klotho Scientific Studies 1
haidut Estrogen Lowers T, DHT, And Fertility; Inhibits 5α-Reductase (5-AR) Scientific Studies 13
Mr.Cacciatore DHEA Agonizes Estrogen Beta Receptor Male Issues 0
Velve921 Lowered Estrogen And Feeling Overly Chill And Relaxed Ask For Help or Advice 25
Opioidus Is There A Medication That Actually Antagonizes Estrogen? Male Issues 15
rzero Breast Cancer Survivors Who Use Estrogenic Botanical Supplements Have Lower Serum Estrogen Levels Scientific Studies 20
B New Research Suggests The Conversion Of Testosterone To Estrogen In The Brain Is Crucial For Male Se Ask For Help or Advice 40
Gadreel Is Celery Seed Good For Lowering Estrogen? Ask For Help or Advice 0
bluefish Dairy, Estrogen, Etc Etc Diet 4
haidut Lipolysis / FFA Drive Breast Cancer By Promoting Estrogen Signalling Scientific Studies 0
P Estrogen And Attraction Science 50
Mauritio Methylene Blue Increases Thyroid , Decreases Estrogen And Prolactin Scientific Studies 40
Harryedgar Fat Loss, PUFA, Estrogen Detox And Increased Metabolism Weight 0
haidut Estrogen Directly Causes Polycystic Ovary Syndrome (PCOS) Scientific Studies 23
haidut Male Sexual Function Does NOT Require Estrogen Scientific Studies 20
haidut Estrogen And Histamine, Not HPV, Drive Cervical Cancer Scientific Studies 6
ScurveDream Long Chins, Big Ears, Long/narrow Faces = GH, Estrogen? Ask For Help or Advice 1
Hans I Got 99 Problems, But The Estrogen In Milk Ain’t One Articles & Scientific Studies 20
C Tribulus Terrestris (TT) Increases Estrogen? Supplements, Pharmaceutical Drugs 8
C Vitamin E Crashing Estrogen? Vitamins 6

Similar threads